US, Russia, and China Clash Over Iran at UN Security Council
The five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council are involved in a fierce debate regarding the discussion of sanctions on Iran. Russia and China maintain that the provisions for reinstating UN sanctions against Iran have expired, whereas the United States, along with the United Kingdom and France, argue that they should be implemented.
This dispute, as reported by Anadolu Agency on Friday (11/9/2026), occurred during a crucial session on Thursday (10/9) local time, discussing the legitimacy of international sanctions against Iran and the reinstatement of UN sanctions based on the ‘snapback’ provision in the 2025 nuclear agreement.
The ‘snapback’ provision, established in the 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), was designed to automatically reinstate UN Security Council Chapter VII sanctions if Iran violates the agreement. This provision bypasses the veto power held by the five permanent members of the Security Council.
“The mechanism to reinstate previously adopted Security Council resolutions regarding Iran, a mechanism contained in Resolution 2231, has not been activated, due to various legal and procedural reasons,” stated the Russian diplomatic representative, while demanding a procedural vote to block the briefing agenda regarding the 1737 Sanctions Committee.
The 1737 Sanctions Committee is a body under the UN Security Council, established through Resolution 1737 to oversee the implementation of nuclear-related sanctions against Iran.
Moscow argues that UN Resolution 2231, which endorsed the JCPOA, expired on 18 October 2025. According to Russia, the non-proliferation agenda was removed from the UN Security Council’s list of active issues on that date.
The Moscow diplomatic envoy further emphasised that the 1737 Sanctions Committee has effectively ceased to exist since 2015 and that no legal basis remains to discuss its performance.
The Chinese diplomatic representative supported Russia’s argument, with Beijing warning against any unilateral actions regarding the matter.
“A handful of members, ignoring differing views, are insisting on forcing the reinstatement of Council sanctions against Iran and convening Council meetings based on an agenda that has been removed,” stated the Chinese diplomatic representative before the members of the Security Council.
The Chinese representative added that such steps deepen institutional divisions and hinder political solutions. Beijing expressed “deep concern” and stated it “strongly opposes” such measures.
Western delegations firmly rejected the arguments of Russia and China, stating that the sanctions regime has been legally reactivated following Iran’s violations of the nuclear agreement.
“Regardless of these politically charged matters, facts remain facts. Committee 1737 exists,” asserted the US diplomatic representative, accusing Russia and China of attempting to undermine Security Council decisions to protect Iran.
In their argument, the UK diplomatic representative explained that the UK, together with France and Germany, initiated the ‘snapback’ mechanism fully in accordance with Resolution 2231, citing “significant failures in meeting obligations” by Iran.
Meanwhile, the French diplomatic representative emphasised that the UN Security Council resolution has been restored, along with the mandate of the 1737 Sanctions Committee.
The UN Security Council ultimately held a vote, resulting in 11 votes in favour of adopting the meeting’s temporary agenda, while two voted against and two abstained. This result thwarted the efforts of Russia and China to halt the crucial meeting.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/us-russia-and-china-clash-over-iran-at-un-security-council-1789106457)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/internasional/d-8658167/ribut-ribut-as-dan-rusia-china-soal-iran-di-dewan-keamanan-pbb), translated from Indonesian