US Political Map: Republican Strongholds Growing in Population, but...
Population growth in several regions that have traditionally served as Republican Party strongholds has the potential to shift the political representation map of the United States following the 2030 Census.
States such as Texas and Florida are projected to gain additional seats in the House of Representatives due to faster population growth. Conversely, California and several other states are at risk of losing seats.
However, an increase in representation for regions currently leaning Republican does not automatically translate to a strengthening of the Republican Party. An analysis by The Economist indicates that demographic changes in ‘Red America’ are far more complex.
Population growth is determined not only by births but also by deaths and migration. In terms of births, Republican-leaning regions still hold an advantage. In 2024, the total fertility rate in counties that typically vote Republican reached 1.8 children per woman, higher than the 1.4 recorded in Democratic counties.
Higher Mortality Rates
This advantage in birth rates is being offset by higher mortality rates. Citing The Economist’s analysis, age-adjusted death rates in Republican counties in 2024 were approximately 18% higher than in Democratic counties. This gap widens to around 27% when comparing the most consistently supportive regions for each party.
This disparity is also evident in life expectancy. In counties that most consistently vote Democratic, life expectancy reaches 80.7 years, whereas in the most consistently Republican counties, it is around 77.4 years. As a result, the number of deaths has now exceeded births in consistently Republican counties for the first time since at least 1982. The natural population growth in these areas currently stands at approximately minus 0.4 per 1,000 inhabitants, whereas Democratic counties still record a natural growth of about 2.8 per 1,000 inhabitants.
Migration as a Population Driver
Despite weakening natural growth, Republican regions continue to grow thanks to domestic migration. Recent estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau show that Texas and Florida recorded the largest positive net domestic migration in 2024, while California and New York experienced significant net outflows.
Historically, migration from other parts of the US has increased the population of Republican counties by about 0.5% per year. In contrast, Democratic counties lose about 0.6% of their population annually due to domestic migration. A different pattern is observed in international migration; the influx of overseas immigrants adds about 0.5% per year to the population of Democratic counties, compared to only 0.1% in Republican counties.
These shifts are altering the distribution of the population across states. Jonathan Cervas from Carnegie Mellon University estimates that Texas could gain four additional House seats after the 2030 Census, while Florida could potentially gain three. Conversely, California is expected to lose four seats, while New York and Illinois are each expected to lose one.
However, these additional seats represent increased representation for the states, not automatically more seats for the Republican Party.
Population Growth Does Not Mean Party Expansion
This is where demographic change becomes more complex. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) data analysed by The Economist shows that the fastest-growing Republican counties are receiving many newcomers from regions with different political characteristics. In 2022-2023, more than 20% of newcomers to the fastest-growing Republican counties came from regions that consistently vote Democratic, while about 40% came from competitive regions.
This pattern is beginning to manifest in political support trends. Before 2016, Republican counties with faster population growth tended to support the Republican Party more strongly than slower-growing counties. Now, that pattern has reversed. Support for the Republicans is relatively stronger in counties with slower population growth, while support in several fast-growing counties is weakening.
In essence, while population growth may increase the political weight of states like Texas and Florida, this does not necessarily correlate with an increase in support for the Republican Party.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/us-political-map-republican-strongholds-growing-in-population-but-1790175147)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20260923110515-128-770176/peta-politik-as-populasi-kantong-suara-partai-republik-naik-tapi), translated from Indonesian