US Judge Blocks Trump Rule Limiting Stay of Foreign Students and Journalists
A federal judge in Massachusetts, F. Dennis Saylor, has temporarily blocked a rule from the administration of US President Donald Trump that would limit the duration of stay for foreign students, academics, exchange programme participants, and journalists in the US.
The decision was issued on Monday (14/9), one day before the new rules from the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) were scheduled to take effect. Saylor ruled that the justifications used by the DHS to implement the policy were extremely weak.
The rules, published by the DHS on 17 July, set a limit on the duration of stay for student and academic visa holders to four years. Meanwhile, foreign journalists on I visas would be limited to 240 days and would be required to apply for extensions to remain in the US.
In his considerations, Saylor noted that the policy lacked a sufficiently strong connection to the national security and visa abuse prevention reasons presented by the government. “The weakness and lack of connection between the rule and the reasons provided raise legitimate questions as to whether the true purpose is not to maintain national security and protect our borders, but rather to achieve other undisclosed goals, such as asserting greater government control over academic and press institutions,” stated Saylor’s ruling, as reported by Anadolu on Wednesday (16/9).
Under the proposed new system, foreign students would no longer be able to rely on a stay based on the duration of their educational programme. They would have to obtain extensions if their studies or research exceeded the specified limit. For foreign journalists, the rule also established an extension mechanism, which is feared will increase the administrative burden on media workers operating in the US.
Saylor’s ruling has a national impact and temporarily maintains the old system while the legal process regarding the rule continues. However, the judge has not permanently overturned the DHS rule, and the US government retains the option to appeal.
The blocked policy was expected to affect approximately 1.6 million F visa holders pursuing undergraduate or postgraduate education, as well as around 500,000 J visa holders participating in exchange programmes.
DHS Defends Trump Policy
The DHS defended the policy, arguing that the government needs to curb potential abuse of the visa system. The department also criticised the court decision that halted the implementation of the new rules. The DHS stated that the public should be grateful to Trump for taking firm action against widespread fraud to ensure that only those truly intending to study in the United States are granted such privileges.
Despite criticising the court’s decision, the DHS has not yet stated whether it will appeal the ruling. In his decision, Saylor assessed that the government failed to show adequate evidence that foreign students were fraudulently using their status as part of the issue the new rules intended to address. He instead highlighted the potential economic and educational impact if the policy were enforced.
“The damage to the higher education system and the United States economy is likely to be immense,” said Saylar. “The government has acknowledged that compliance costs alone are likely to reach more than US$250 million in the first year,” he continued.
The judge also warned that these changes could make the US less attractive to international students and researchers, particularly as American universities face challenges in maintaining student numbers. “Many US colleges and universities are already struggling due to declining student numbers caused by demographic changes. They will also suffer a massive economic impact (if the rule is implemented),” Saylor explained.
The ruling temporarily maintains the system that allows foreign students to remain in the US as long as they meet the requirements of their educational or exchange programmes. The debate regarding the restrictions on stay and their impact on higher education, the economy, and the US immigration system is set to continue through the subsequent legal process.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/us-judge-blocks-trump-rule-limiting-stay-of-foreign-students-and-journalists-1789570487)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/internasional/934205/hakim-as-blokir-aturan-trump-batasi-masa-tinggal-mahasiswa-dan-jurnalis-asing), translated from Indonesian