Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

US Defence Secretary Faces Impeachment Threat Over Alleged Breach of Rules

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
US Defence Secretary Faces Impeachment Threat Over Alleged Breach of Rules
Image: CNBC Indonesia

US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth faces the threat of impeachment, with the House of Representatives potentially beginning a vote as early as next week.

The threat emerged after Republicans lost the midterm elections on Tuesday, 3 November 2026, enabling Democrats to take control of Congress for the remainder of US President Donald Trump’s term.

The US war against Iran is one of the issues putting pressure on the Trump administration, including Hegseth, who has played a key role in the military operation.

Republican Representative Thomas Massie said he would reintroduce a motion to impeach Hegseth when Congress resumes next week.

Massie had previously sought Hegseth’s impeachment, arguing that US military involvement in the war against Iran had proceeded without congressional approval.

The criticism intensified after the midterm results showed Republicans losing control of the House and Senate for the coming period. US Vice-President JD Vance has also publicly acknowledged that the Iran war was one reason for his party’s defeat.

Despite mounting pressure, Trump continues to support Hegseth. Speaking to reporters on Thursday, 5 November 2026, Trump said his defence secretary had done a very good job.

Hegseth has rejected the allegations. In a video posted on social media platform X, he called the impeachment effort baseless and said he would continue carrying out his duties.

Trump’s support, however, would not automatically stop impeachment proceedings if Congress decided to move ahead.

The issue is that Hegseth is neither the president nor the vice-president, but a secretary appointed directly by Trump.

In the United States, impeachment is not limited to the president. Article II, Section 4 of the US Constitution provides for the removal through impeachment of the president, vice-president and certain federal civil officers.

This provision allows Congress to hold senior officials to account, including Cabinet members such as the defence secretary.

However, an official cannot be impeached solely because they are considered to have performed poorly or have lost political support.

The Constitution sets out three principal grounds for impeachment:

  • Treason

  • Bribery

  • Other high crimes and misdemeanours

The last term has a broad scope and remains a subject of debate in US constitutional law. Conduct that could provide grounds for impeachment need not amount to an ordinary criminal offence.

In Hegseth’s case, the central issue concerns the US government’s decision to wage war against Iran without congressional approval.

The US Constitution divides military powers between the president and Congress: the president serves as commander-in-chief of the armed forces, while Congress has the power to declare war.

The division of powers is also related to the War Powers Resolution of 1973.

The law requires the president to report certain deployments of troops to Congress within 48 hours. If a military operation continues without the necessary authorisation, it generally sets a 60-day limit, with a limited additional period for withdrawing troops in certain circumstances.

The application of the law is frequently contested by the government and Congress.

Massie’s allegations against Hegseth will therefore be subject to a lengthy political and constitutional process.

How does impeachment work in the US?

Under the Constitution and official explanations from the US Senate, impeachment involves two institutions with different responsibilities.

The House has the authority to bring and approve impeachment charges, while the Senate is responsible for trying the case and deciding whether the official should be removed.

The process begins in the House of Representatives. House members can introduce articles of impeachment setting out allegations against the official.

The proposal may be examined by a committee or brought directly to a House vote under certain procedures.

If a simple majority approves it, the official is formally impeached. For example, if all 435 House members are present and voting, at least 218 votes in favour are required.

Once the House has approved and transmitted the articles of impeachment, the Senate handles the case under its impeachment trial rules.

At the trial, House representatives act as prosecutors, while the accused official may present a defence.

The Senate also has the authority to determine procedures, including the examination of evidence and witnesses. In certain circumstances, it can make a procedural decision to dismiss the case without completing a full trial.

The Constitution requires the support of at least two-thirds of senators present to convict an official. If all 100 senators are present, at least 67 votes are needed.

If Hegseth is convicted through this process, he must be removed from office. The Senate may also decide to bar him from holding certain federal offices in the future.

If the vote falls short of the required threshold, he will not be removed.

A US secretary of war has faced impeachment before

The impeachment of a Cabinet secretary is not without precedent in US history.

In 1876, US Secretary of War William Belknap, who served under President Ulysses S. Grant, faced impeachment proceedings amid allegations of corruption involving the award of trading rights at a military facility.

Belknap chose to resign on 2 March 1876, shortly before the House was due to vote.

His resignation did not stop the proceedings. The House approved the impeachment and referred the case to the Senate.

Belknap was ultimately acquitted after the number of senators voting to convict fell short of the two-thirds threshold.

The case became an important precedent, demonstrating that resignation does not necessarily end impeachment proceedings, although the Senate’s authority to try former officials remains open to debate.

More recently, the House impeached US Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas in 2024. The Senate, however, rejected the articles of impeachment through a procedural decision.

Both cases show that impeachment by the House does not necessarily result in an official’s removal from office.

More from 6 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/us-defence-secretary-faces-impeachment-threat-over-alleged-breach-of-rules-1793973047)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20261106142013-128-782997/menteri-pertahanan-mau-diberhentikan-dianggap-langgar-aturan-ini), translated from Indonesian
Print