Up in arms
Up in arms
While it is easy to understand many Indonesians these days are
haunted by the constant threat of violence and unrest, the
attorney general's decision over the weekend to arm hundreds of
his staff with sticks, "to fend off radical groups" protesting at
his office, is bound to raise some questions.
"We need to protect ourselves and our office from radical
groups who tend to do damage and to loot and burn things. From
now on we must train ourselves and be ready to face that kind of
situation," Attorney General Andi M. Ghalib explained to
reporters.
While declining to identify those guilty parties by name,
Ghalib claimed they were present among the hundreds of protesting
students who camped out behind his office last May.
Given the authorities' performance -- or rather, non-
performance -- in identifying and stopping the provocateurs who
are thought to have been behind many of the disturbances of
recent weeks and months, one may be inclined to disbelieve such a
claim.
Yet, it could just as well be that there is more substance to
the attorney general's statement than people are willing to
believe. After all, the commander of the stick-wielding brigade
is Syamsu Djalaludin, the deputy attorney general for
intelligence and a former chief of the military police.
That being the case, and considering the authorities' sad
history in identifying provocateurs, it is certainly heartening
to learn that they have for once immediately recognized those
malevolent elements present among student protesters.
On the other hand, one might wish that the authorities in
charge of security could show an equal adroitness in sorting out
suspected riot masterminds and instigators from the innocent
masses in the various cases of serious unrest, whose social and
political implications no doubt far outstrip those of the
protests at the attorney general's office.
Without denigrating the attorney general's office, it must be
said that the apparent inability on the part of our leaders, both
civilian and military, to uncover the many cases of official
corruption and violence in our society is one of the most
abrasive factors contributing to the present crisis of confidence
in the government and the military.
So far, not a single major case of violence has been
satisfactorily settled or even brought to light -- from the
kidnappings of prodemocracy activists throughout the disastrous
May riots to the shooting incidents at Trisakti and Semanggi, the
Ketapang (Jakarta) riots and, most recently, the carnage in
Ambon.
And as for the attorney general's office, people are still
hankering to see a major corruption case tried and resolved. As
things stand at present, it is hard to blame people for
suspecting a diversionary maneuver behind every official move.
To return to the stick-wielding attorneys: The best that this
may achieve is to affirm for the public that old habits do indeed
die hard. In this case the old habits are not only refusing to
die, but appear to be contagious.
One would have thought that all the recent violence -- and in
particular our experience with the Pam Swakarsa civilian militia
during last November's session of the People's Consultative
Assembly -- has taught us that brute force is not the cure-all
for society's problems. Indeed, violence tends to breed more
violence.
Thus, if it is peace and order that the authorities want, the
best they can do is to honestly try to resolve, rather than
prolong, each and every problem that is bothering the public. Old
habits may die hard, but it is never too late to learn.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/up-in-arms-1447899208-1424696)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post