University Student Challenges 1 Syawal Determination Rule in Constitutional Court
Ahmad Fathu Shabri, a law student at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta (UMY), has submitted a judicial review petition to the Constitutional Court (MK) regarding the regulations governing the determination of 1 Syawal, which serves as the basis for determining Eid al-Fitr.
The petitioner is challenging Article 52A of Law Number 3 of 2006 concerning Religious Courts. According to Ahmad, the provision creates legal uncertainty because the government can only officially determine 1 Syawal through an ‘isbat’ session held just one day before Eid al-Fitr.
Furthermore, he argues that the article indirectly provides legal legitimacy only to the ‘rukyat’ (moon sighting) method for determining the start of Hijri months. Consequently, the ‘hisab’ (astronomical calculation) method, practised by a portion of the Muslim community, appears not to receive equal recognition from the state.
“This law also structurally labels our method (hislam) as invalid and unofficial in the eyes of the state,” Ahmad stated during the Preliminary Examination of Case Number 224/PUU-XXIV/2026, held online on Thursday, 25 June 2026.
The contested Article 52A of the Religious Court Law states that religious courts provide ‘isbat’ for ‘rukyat hilal’ testimony in determining the start of Hijri months. According to the petitioner, this provision contradicts Article 29 paragraph (2) in conjunction with Article 28E paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, which guarantees freedom of religion and the right to practice one’s beliefs.
In his petition, Ahmad claims to have suffered direct constitutional loss. As a practitioner of the ‘hisab’ method, which often determines 1 Syawal earlier than the government, he claims to face obstacles in performing religious duties and conducting social life.
“This occurs because the government only provides single institutional legitimacy to the ‘rukyat’ method,” said Ahmad.
He also reported difficulties in performing Eid al-Fitr prayers earlier due to the lack of available congregational prayer locations or fields. This is because local officials and the community generally wait for the results of the government’s ‘isbat’ session before providing such facilities.
Additionally, Ahmad argues that the phrase “testimony” in Article 52A has closed the door to judicial recognition of early-month proofs through mathematical-astronomical approaches or ‘hisab hakiki’. According to him, this condition violates Article 28I paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution by making the results of the ‘isbat’ session the sole basis for determining national holidays.
In his petition, Ahmad requests the Constitutional Court to declare Article 52A of the Religious Court Law in conflict with the 1945 Constitution and therefore without binding legal force. Alternatively, he requests that the article be declared conditionally unconstitutional so long as it is interpreted as only recognising the ‘rukyat’ method as the sole basis for determining the start of Hijri months without providing equal recognition to the ‘hisab hakiki’ method.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/university-student-challenges-1-syawal-determination-rule-in-constitutional-court-1782464159)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2110521/mahasiswa-umy-menggugat-aturan-penetapan-1-syawal-ke-mk), translated from Indonesian