Unempathetic Comments Towards Yurizal Under Scrutiny: What Lies Behind Them?
The case of comments deemed unempathetic by a number of medical staff towards a patient named Yurizal Tri Chaerawan has become a focus of public attention. Scrutiny of the case has intensified after it emerged that Yurizal died on 31 July 2026.
The case has raised questions among the public: why would a healthcare worker make comments considered unempathetic towards a patient? Is such behaviour truly triggered by pressure or work-related stress?
Although many suspect that unempathetic comments from healthcare workers are triggered by pressure or work-related stress, Dr Wiweka said this cannot yet be confirmed and still requires further research. However, he stressed that whatever the cause, doctors are still not justified in acting outside ethical principles when dealing with patients.
“That would need further research. But whatever it is, whether a doctor is burnt out or otherwise, when dealing with a patient they are not permitted to lose their temper or act outside the ethical realm. They must still prioritise ethics,” he said when contacted by VIVA.co.id on Wednesday, 5 August 2026.
Wiweka explained that a doctor fundamentally adheres to the principle taught by Hippocrates, namely ‘first, do no harm’. This principle applies not only to medical procedures but also to the way doctors communicate with patients.
“First of all, we must not cause harm. Harm here in two senses, both physical and verbal. A doctor is required to do that, it is obligatory,” he said.
Furthermore, Wiweka stressed that every doctor bears a moral and professional responsibility pledged through the professional oath taken upon being sworn in. Therefore, doctors are obliged to practise medicine in accordance with their professional oath and the prevailing code of ethics.
“One of the oaths relates to the protection of patients. And they are bound, if they are members of the Indonesian Medical Association, they are bound by Kodeki (the Indonesian Medical Ethics Code). We have Kodeki with 21 articles. Those 21 articles are divided into four major categories: obligations to general duties, obligations to patients, obligations to colleagues, and obligations to oneself,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/unempathetic-comments-towards-yurizal-under-scrutiny-what-lies-behind-them-1785999157)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1919358-komentar-nirempati-ke-yurizal-jadi-sorotan-apa-penyebab-di-baliknya), translated from Indonesian