Unej legal expert says bounty for catching muggers could violate human rights
Jember, East Java (ANTARA) - Professor I Gede Widhiana Suarda, a legal expert at the University of Jember (Unej), has stated that a bounty scheme for catching street muggers could potentially violate human rights (HAM), as it may trigger acts of violence in the form of mob justice against street criminals.
“Such a bounty has the potential to violate human rights and encourage people taking the law into their own hands, which could end in the loss of someone’s life,” he said at the Unej campus in East Java on Wednesday.
According to him, a purely repressive approach will never resolve the root causes of street crime as long as the state has been unable to guarantee public welfare through comprehensive policies.
“More than eight decades after Indonesia’s independence, a sense of security remains a fundamental need that has not been fully felt by the public,” said Gede, who is also Dean of Unej’s Faculty of Law.
He said the fear of becoming a victim of muggings, bag snatchings or other street crimes now haunts public activities, even influencing how people go about their daily lives.
“When people are afraid to come home late at night, and parents are anxious about letting their children go to school, that is a signal that the state must seriously evaluate the public protection system,” he said.
“In criminology there is a term called criminogenic factors, namely a condition or policy that can actually trigger the emergence of new criminal acts. This could legitimise the public acting outside legal channels and give rise to vigilante practices,” he said.
He explained that cases of mobs beating suspected criminals to death must not be regarded as successes in eradicating crime, but rather as an alarm that law enforcement must not shift into enforcement by the masses.
“The primary responsibility for enforcement remains with the Indonesian National Police as part of the criminal justice system. Community participation is important, but only insofar as it supports the creation of security, not in taking over the function of the state,” he said.
Gede said that eradicating street muggers is indeed a necessity, but the methods used must not end up creating new crimes driven by uncontrolled mass rage.
“The state must win not only through law enforcement, but also through policies that deliver a sense of security and welfare for all the people of Indonesia,” he said.
Previously, West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi announced a bounty of Rp5 million to Rp50 million for residents who manage to subdue perpetrators of theft, pickpocketing, bag snatching, mugging or robbery, and then hand them over to the police alive.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/unej-legal-expert-says-bounty-for-catching-muggers-could-violate-human-rights-1785336904)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5671660/pakar-hukum-unej-sebut-sayembara-tangkap-begal-berpotensi-langgar-ham), translated from Indonesian