Understanding the Concept of 'Living Law' in the New Criminal Code
Deputy Minister of Law Edward Omar Sharif Hiariej has explained the legal boundaries of ‘living law’—customary law existing within society—as stipulated in Article 2, paragraph (1) of Law Number 1 of 2023 regarding the new Criminal Code (KUHP). During the third hearing of Petition Number 295/PUU-XXIV/2026 at the Constitutional Court in Jakarta on Monday (14/9), the Deputy Minister stated that the contention that this article contradicts the principle of a constitutional state is unfounded, as the requirement for judges to explore living law has long existed in the Judiciary Law.
“In essence, the substance of this article is not new,” said Hiarable, as he is affectionately known.
Furthermore, Hiariej explained that the application of living law is not intended solely for criminal conviction, but can also be used to exempt individuals from criminal liability, serving as an embodiment of the principle of balance within the Criminal Code. He added that Article 2, paragraph (1) of the KUHP is applied only when an act is not covered by the written Criminal Code, and specifically for minor offences.
“This article is not intended to revive dead customary criminal law institutions, but rather to provide state legitimacy for customary criminal law institutions that are still in effect,” Hiariej stated.
Additionally, the Deputy Minister dismissed the petitioners’ argument that Article 2, paragraph (1) allows for direct criminalisation based on unwritten customary norms. He asserted that the validity of living law as a criminal offence does not occur automatically; it must first be regulated within Regional Regulations (Perda) concerning customary offences, as stipulated in Government Regulation Number 55 of 2025.
“Therefore, living law in society is not a norm that law enforcement officers can directly use as a basis for prosecution,” Hiariej emphasised.
Hiariej appeared as legal counsel for the President to provide testimony regarding the judicial review of Article 2, paragraph (1) of the new KUHP, filed by nine advocates from the Rumah Advocare Indonesia organisation. In the preliminary hearing on Tuesday (11/8), the petitioners challenged the phrase “law that lives in society” within the three norms, arguing that it is unwritten, not officially published, and lacks clear boundaries.
The petitioners argued that the article in question has caused constitutional loss, specifically the loss of legal certainty in their professional practice as advocates. They maintained that advocates have an obligation to provide legal defence based on clear, written, and predictable positive law. The petitioners believe the loss is potential, as the implementation of the new KUHP creates legal uncertainty where an act could be declared a criminal offence based on unwritten, unpublicised, and ill-defined customary parameters.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/understanding-the-concept-of-living-law-in-the-new-criminal-code-1789393896)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/933303/ini-pengertian-living-law-dalam-kuhp-baru), translated from Indonesian