Understanding Simon Tisdall's Analysis: Is Trump, Not Iran, the Threat to the World?
The ongoing conflict between the United States and Iran continues to fuel geopolitical turmoil in the Middle East, forcing the world to reconsider a fundamental question: who truly poses the greatest threat to global peace? For decades, the dominant Western narrative has positioned Iran as the primary source of regional instability. However, Simon Tisdall, a senior foreign affairs journalist for The Guardian, presents a provocative thesis: it is not Iran, but rather Donald Trump’s leadership style and foreign policy that represent a more significant danger.
Tisdall’s analysis suggests that the core issue is not merely Iran’s existence as a regional power, but the United States’ tendency—particularly under Trump—to employ unilateralism, maximum pressure campaigns, and military threats while disregarding multilateral diplomatic mechanisms. This approach, he argues, heightens the risk of broader global conflict. The critique finds support in international relations theory; political scientist John J. Mearsheimer’s concept of offensive realism posits that great powers’ pursuit of dominance is often the primary source of conflict. Similarly, Joseph S. Nye Jr.’s concept of soft power underscores that global leadership is built not only on military might but also on legitimacy, trust, and international cooperation.
This is not to absolve Iran of its own controversial actions. The country remains under intense international scrutiny for its nuclear programme, its support for armed proxies across the region, and its enduring tensions with Israel and other Middle Eastern states. To simplify the conflict by blaming a single actor would fail to capture the complex geopolitical reality. The United Nations Charter reinforces this by stipulating that the use of force must be a last resort, with peaceful dispute resolution and respect for national sovereignty forming the bedrock of the post-World War II international order.
Tisdall’s critique gains relevance when considering the moral responsibilities that accompany great power. As Lord Acton famously warned, power tends to corrupt, a caution that applies to nations as much as to individuals. This perspective is echoed in Islamic teachings, such as the Qur’anic verse (Al-Anfal 8:61) which instructs believers to incline towards peace if the enemy does so, and the principle that killing one innocent soul is akin to killing all of humanity (Al-Ma’idah 5:32). Ultimately, the analysis suggests that the greatest threat to the world may not come from a labelled enemy, but from a superpower that neglects international law, diplomacy, and humanitarian principles. True peace is born not from the victory of one side over another, but from respect for human dignity and the establishment of justice for all nations.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/understanding-simon-tisdalls-analysis-is-trump-not-iran-the-threat-to-the-world-1784479871)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/772164/memahami-analisis-simon-tisdall-trump-bukan-iran-adalah-ancaman-bagi-dunia), translated from Indonesian