Understanding S&P Global: The Root of the World Financial Crisis
S&P Global Ratings wields immense influence over global financial markets. A single rating decision from this agency can determine investor confidence in everything from private assets to sovereign nations, including Indonesia.
However, S& and P’s prominent reputation is accompanied by a dark history. The rating agency was implicated as a cause of the 2008 global financial crisis, which is regarded as one of the largest economic collapses since the Great Depression of the late 1920s.
At that time, many US-based mortgage-backed financial products received high ratings, despite containing significant underlying risks. When the wave of mortgage defaults occurred, these previously perceived-as-safe products collapsed, dragging the global financial markets into crisis.
S&P’s Dark Legacy in the 2008 Financial Crisis
Before the global financial crisis erupted, many US mortgage-based financial products received high ratings from agencies, including Standard & Poor’s, the former name of S&P Global Ratings. These products included residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) and collateralised debt obligations (CDO).
Essentially, RMBS are debt securities formed from a pool of home loans, while CDOs are financial products containing a pool of debt assets, including mortgage-based bonds. The issue was that many of the underlying mortgages originated from high-risk borrowers, known as “subprime mortgages.”
When many borrowers began defaulting on their mortgage payments, the value of these financial products plummeted. However, before the crisis fully broke, many of these instruments had already received high ratings and were sold to global investors. On paper, these products appeared safe; in reality, the underlying risks were far greater than investors understood.
The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, the official US government commission established to investigate the causes of the 2008 crisis, identified the failure of rating agencies as a critical component of the crisis. The commission assessed that the three major rating agencies were primary drivers of the mortgage-backed product explosion, as these products were difficult to market without a high-rating stamp of approval.
Criticism of rating agencies arose because their business model was seen to harbour conflicts of interest. In many cases, the issuers of financial products paid the rating agencies to obtain a rating. This led to criticisms that agencies might be incentivised to maintain high ratings to avoid losing clients to competitors.
Scrutiny of S&P continued years after the crisis. In 2015, the US Department of Justice, along with 19 states and the District of Columbia, announced a US$1.375 billion legal settlement with Standard & Poor’s Financial Services. The settlement related to allegations that S&P provided excessively high ratings to RMBS and CDOs prior to the 2008 crisis. US authorities also noted that S&P acknowledged certain behaviours regarding RMBS and CDO ratings during the 2004-2007 period.
The 2008 case has led to increased oversight of rating agencies. While ratings remain a vital benchmark for investors, the crisis demonstrated that a rating is not an absolute guarantee. A credit rating is an opinion on risk, not a guarantee that an instrument or a country is immune to default.
Consequently, when S&P assigns a rating to a country like Indonesia, the market looks beyond just the numerical rating. Investors also examine the rationale behind the rating, the provided outlook, and the risks highlighted by the agency.
Credit Rating: A Measure of Investor Confidence
What exactly is an S&P Global credit rating, and why is it important for Indonesia? A credit rating is an assessment of the ability of a country, company, or institution to meet its debt obligations. In a national context, this is known as a sovereign credit rating. Rating agencies assess the capacity and willingness of a government to repay its debt, both in local and foreign currencies.
The higher a country’s rating, the lower the perceived default risk. Conversely, a lower rating indicates higher perceived risk for investors. S&P Global Ratings explains that a credit rating is a forward-looking opinion regarding the credit quality of a debt issuer or instrument.
While these ratings do not guarantee that a country or company will not default, they serve as a crucial benchmark for investors making decisions.
Investment Grade: A Critical Level in Debt Rating
In the rating hierarchy, classifications are generally divided into two major groups: investment grade and non-investment grade (or speculative grade). Investment grade indicates that a country or issuer is deemed to have sufficient capacity to meet its financial obligations. Non-investment grade indicates higher credit risk.
In the S&P Global scale, the investment grade category ranges from BBB- to AAA. This means countries rated BBB-, BBB, BBB+, A, AA, and AAA are still considered within the investment-grade group. With a BBB rating, Indonesia sits two levels above the lower limit of investment grade, as S&P’s lowest investment-grade threshold is BBB-.
This implies that Indonesia is still viewed as having adequate capacity to meet its debt obligations. However, a BBB position also means Indonesia has not yet reached the high-tier rating groups such as A, AA, or AAA.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/understanding-s-p-global-the-root-of-the-world-financial-crisis-1783500690)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20260603142219-128-739780/mengenal-sp-global-biang-kerok-krisis-keuangan-dunia), translated from Indonesian