Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Uncanny Valley: The Phenomenon of Humans Rejecting Artificial Intelligence (AI)?

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Technology
Uncanny Valley: The Phenomenon of Humans Rejecting Artificial Intelligence (AI)?
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Uncanny Valley: Is the Phenomenable Causing Humans to Reject Artificial Intelligence (AI)?

Among the two opposing groups regarding the intensive development of artificial intelligence (AI), the group that views AI as becoming increasingly human-like appears to be the most likely to reject it. These two groups are: first, those who consider AI to be a result of development that runs parallel to human evolution.

Today’s technological reality can be traced through the development trajectories of previous technologies, which are linked to human needs. The printing press, the steam engine, factory systems, computing, information technology, and now AI, are all available in accordance with the interests of human evolution.

The continuity between human evolution and its accompanying technology was revealed by Tom Chatfield in 2019, in “Technology in Deep Time: How it Evolves Alongside Us”. He stated that human ancestors were no different from other animals in the initial creation and development of tools. Some were even able to develop and pass down specific characteristic practices.

Such as the New Caledonian crow, which commonly uses tools or creates simple hooks from plants to help it obtain food. The difference is that humans are able to transform that skill through experimentation that combines natural forces.

Such as fire for cooking, which was eventually developed for smelting metal; gravity becoming systems of levers, inclined planes, pulleys, wheels, and counterweights; and mental strength becoming symbolic art, the ability to count, read, and write.

A similar sentiment was expressed by economist W. Brian Arthur in 2009, as cited by Chatfield from his book, “The Nature of Technology”. He noted that all new technologies are essentially combinations of previous technologies. The entire process follows an evolutionary path similar to life itself.

The printing press developed by Johannes Gutenberg in 1440 was based on existing technology. Its entire origins can be traced back through a sequence of earlier technologies. From the perspective of this group, the existence of technology as an accompaniment to human evolution is always aligned with human interests.

The second group, however, believes that technological development does not always run parallel to the trajectory of human evolution. Its existence does not always support human interests. This includes a developmental path that may start in parallel but, at a certain point, surpasses the human process.

The theory explaining this state was proposed by Tim Mucci in 2024, in “What is The Technological Singularity?”. He mentioned a state known as the technological singularity: a theoretical scenario describing uncontrollable technological growth that cannot be reversed to its original state, triggering unexpected changes in human civilisation.

Technological singularity is driven by AI that surpasses human cognitive abilities. At that point, AI can enhance its own capabilities independently. The term singularity is a mathematical concept where machines do not merely match but exceed human intelligence.

Within the framework of evolution, the cycle continues at a rapid pace. Humans are unable to predict, mitigate, or stop the process. The technological evolution that produced AI is not only autonomous but also capable of innovating beyond human understanding and control.

Technology produces machines that create even more advanced versions of themselves, while displacing humans as the most superior entity. This point could be good news or a disaster for humanity.

And when the second group perceives it as a disaster, the existence of AI is viewed as a threat. This is accompanied by an increase in intensity. Initially, the threat was AI producing incorrect results; then, the threat of AI being misused; followed by the threat of human workers being replaced by AI; and finally, the total threat of AI to human existence.

This increasing intensity places humans in an unpleasant position: still part of civilisation, but no longer playing a role. Consequently, those holding the second view tend to reject AI from its very inception.

One form of this rejection has been identified as a psychological symptom called the ‘uncanny valley’. This phenomenon was first proposed by Masahiro Mori, a Japanese robotics scientist, in 1970. His explanation of the uncanny valley—or bukimi no tani in its original terminology—is a gradual decline in a person’s sense of comfort.

The valley forms as comfort decreases when witnessing an artificial entity that looks and behaves similarly to a human but is not quite natural. For example, a robot dancing to a song, but with jerky, mechanical movements.

Or a chatbot that responds to conversation, but with a voice that sounds like a machine. Or an interactive replica acting as a human friend, but periodically undergoing system updates. All of these evoke a creepy sensation, especially when human cognition fluctuates between seeing the machine as human and the human as a machine.

This reaction of discomfort manifests as disgust, anxiety, or intimidation. It peaks as the artificial entity becomes more human-like. However, when rationality manages to control the discomfort, the decline reverses. This creates the image of a valley: a downward curve that eventually turns upward.

Luis Echavarri, in 2025, in “The ‘Uncanny Valley’: Why Non-Human Characters Dominate AI Narratives”, outlines this process. According to him, the human mind is able to recognise social or emotional cues when something is made “almost” human but has not yet achieved it. This results in a split attitude: an affinity for the resemblance to humans, but also an emergence of discomfort due to the lack of true similarity.

More from 29 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/uncanny-valley-the-phenomenon-of-humans-rejecting-artificial-intelligence-ai-1782748368)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260629220805-14-746666/uncanny-valley-fenomena-manusia-menolak-artificial-intelligence--ai-), translated from Indonesian
Print