UMR Wage vs Cost of Living: Still Viable or Merely Surviving?
The reality is that the UMR wage serves as a benchmark merely for survival. If wages are only sufficient to keep body and soul together until the next day, where does that leave the definition of ‘welfare’ that is so exalted in every policy? For most workers, their wages are nearly equivalent to the price of basic necessities, which continue to rise at an increasingly rapid rate. The stagnation of minimum wage levels has become a growing national social issue, particularly due to the dominance of inadequate wage levels against the increases in food costs, housing, fuel, utilities, and the increasingly extreme urban minimum wage hikes. This applies especially in Indonesia’s urban capitals.
Workers earning minimum wages must support themselves. After accounting for these extreme pressures, combined with the strain of surviving on an almost insufficient economy, they become more cost-conscious. These pressures are both financial and social, as many people lack opportunities to break the endless cycle of minimal economic survival. Extreme rises in the prices of basic necessities, particularly for minimum-wage workers in big cities, have created these extreme pressures, compounded by the need to survive on a nearly inadequate economy, making them more frugal.
The Concept of UMR and Living Needs
The government considers inflation, economic growth, and Living Needs (KHL) to determine a country’s minimum wage (UMR). In theory, UMR should meet the basic needs of a single worker. In practice, UMR does not fulfil the basic needs of a single worker, and standards vary from case to case. Each person’s needs depend on lifestyle, family, location, and other factors. The KHL theory is far from reality, as UMR is set for one person and does not consider families (husband, wife, and two children). For UMR workers in big cities, a decent life might require an air-conditioned rental unit, and satisfying food and recreation needs may not be available. Each worker’s needs differ based on family responsibilities, and their priorities will depend on their savings (for education, motorbikes, etc.).
The Reality of Living Costs in the Field
Settling in metropolitan cities like Jakarta or Surabaya is no longer just a challenge but a heavy financial struggle due to disproportionate living costs. Rent can consume almost your entire salary, eating at a warteg three times a day is about the minimum affordable cost level, and ride-hailing (ojol) is a necessity. Because public transportation is unavailable, other phenomena offer rides at affordable rates. Although expensive, they are the most available option. Beyond basic needs, there are remote work expenses for education, medicines for illnesses, and sending money to relatives in rural areas. Moreover, the average salary in most cities is only enough to maintain the most basic life and leaves no opportunity to save for emergencies. Employees in these areas work under financial pressure because they cannot save.
The Impact of the Imbalance Between UMR and Living Costs
The gap between income and expenditure cycles affects individuals and families in many ways. For example, someone feels extremely financially stressed, leading to habitual depression, heartbreak, and family quarrels. Trillions of dollars worth of dreams, such as funding their children’s education and enjoying a financially peaceful retirement, will vanish. Due to the unbalanced income and expenditure cycle, individual workers suffer financial stress and cannot meet long-term needs. Collectively, this financial imbalance synergy causes broader economic inequality that continues to widen among individuals. If the majority of people in a country, or even in a region, lack the financial power to consume, that country or region, at a broader economic level, will remain in a state of low growth and financial stagnation.
Survival Strategies of Workers
Many workers adopt various coping mechanisms to deal with this situation. Some seek additional night jobs as ride-hailing drivers, cut costs, and have roommates. Others try their luck with small investments or improve their skills to increase income. Unfortunately, these strategies usually do not succeed, and the coping mechanisms formed are often only temporary and proven unsustainable.
Challenges for Companies and Government
Companies face a difficult situation. They realise that to reduce turnover and maintain high productivity, they need to offer competitive wages. However, for micro, small, and medium enterprises (UMKM) with slim profit margins, increases in the Regional Minimum Wage (UMR) cause higher operational costs. Many companies end up reducing working hours, cutting contract employees, or closing branches. It is also expected from the government to create fair wage policies while still considering the economy and businesses. Thus, the need to maintain balance cannot be avoided if all related parties, employees and UMKM, want to be protected.
Conclusion
In big cities with high living costs, the current UMR is a ‘survival benchmark’, not a wage that allows for a decent life.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/umr-wage-vs-cost-of-living-still-viable-or-merely-surviving-1778781552)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/756996/gaji-umr-vs-biaya-hidup-masih-layak-atau-sekedar-bertahan), translated from Indonesian