UI Law Professors Provide 13 Critical Notes on Asset Forfeiture Bill
The Council of Professors of the University of Indonesia Faculty of Law (FHUI) has provided 13 critical notes regarding the Asset For Lack of Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset) as a legal instrument to strengthen the state’s efforts in recovering assets derived from criminal acts.
“Law enforcement must not stop at punishing the perpetrator, but must also ensure that the proceeds of crime are not enjoyed by the perpetrator or other parties,” said FHUI Professor Harkristuti Harkrisnowo during the ‘Professors’ Insights’ event in Depok on Thursday (24/9).
Harkristuti read the 13 notes, the first being that the Asset Forfeiture Bill is a vital part of efforts to strengthen the recovery of criminal proceeds. The orientation of law enforcement should not merely be to punish the perpetrator, but to ensure that the economic benefits of crime are recovered and not continued to be enjoyed by the perpetrator or those benefiting from them.
Secondly, the Asset Forfeiture Bill introduces a significant paradigm shift in law enforcement. While conventional mechanisms are person-oriented (in persona), this Bill introduces an asset-oriented approach (in rem) through non-conviction based forfeiture mechanisms. This is particularly relevant when criminal proceedings cannot proceed normally, such as when a suspect or defendant dies, flees, suffers permanent illness, or due to specific legal reasons where a case cannot be tried.
Thirdly, the mechanism of asset forfeiture without a criminal conviction must not become a shortcut to bypass criminal proceedings. Such mechanisms must be placed within a limited and measurable framework, used only in circumstances justified by law.
Fourthly, the state’s authority to seize assets is immense as it directly relates to the constitutional rights of citizens, particularly the right to property. Therefore, the Asset Forfeial Bill must be built upon the principles of the rule of law, legal certainty, proportionality, due process of law, and the protection of human rights.
Fifthly, the Bill needs to be equipped with strong safeguards, including limitations on the use of forfeiture mechanisms, clear evidentiary regulations, protection for good-faith third parties, limitations on the scope and value of assets that can be seized, and effective judicial oversight.
Sixthly, the reversal of the burden of proof must be formulated very carefully. The state must still possess an adequate initial basis to demonstrate the link between the asset and the criminal act. Consequently, guidelines, indicators, and evidentiary standards must be objective, transparent, clear, and measurable.
Seventhly, the protection of good-faith third parties is paramount. “We must ensure that no one loses their property rights due to something they were unaware of,” she stated. Third parties must have the opportunity to defend their rights, hold an equal position in the judicial process, and obtain restitution if state actions are proven to be erroneous.
Eighthly, judicial oversight must be an inseparable part of the asset forfeiture mechanism. Every state action that limits or takes away an individual’s rights must be subject to review by an independent court. “The greater the authority granted to the state, the stronger the oversight mechanism must be,” she added.
Ninthly, the governance of seized or forfeited assets must be designed to be transparent and accountable. Concentrating too much authority within a single institution—covering seizure, storage, management, and the sale of assets—needs to be balanced with strong oversight to prevent conflicts of interest and abuse of power.
Tenthly, the sale or transfer of assets before a court decision must be conducted with extreme caution. There must be a clear mechanism in place if the court subsequently rules that the asset cannot be forfeited. In this context, the protection of rights and judicial control are vital.
Eleventhly, asset recovery cannot be separated from international cooperation. Modern economic crimes are often transnational; assets can be moved, hidden, or converted in other jurisdictions. Therefore, the asset forfeiture system must support international cooperation in the tracing, freezing, forfeiture, recovery, and management of criminal proceeds.
Twelfthly, while the experiences of various countries are important to study, Indonesia does not need to copy foreign models entirely. Every asset forfeiture mechanism must be adapted to Indonesia’s constitution, legal system, institutional structure, and social conditions.
Thirteenthly, the effectiveness of law enforcement and the protection of human rights should not be seen as contradictory. “Assets that truly originate from criminal acts should not be allowed to be enjoyed by perpetrators,” she explained. However, to determine that an asset originates from a crime, the state must operate based on the law, accountable evidence, a fair process, and effective oversight.
Other professors in attendance included Hikmahanto Juwana and Topo Santoso.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ui-law-professors-provide-13-critical-notes-on-asset-forfeiture-bill-1790251008)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260924174737-12-1407888/dewan-guru-besar-fhui-beri-13-catatan-kritis-soal-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian