UGM Lecturer Highlights Seat Distribution in Election Law Revision
A lecturer from the Department of Politics and Government at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), Alfath Bagus Panuntun El Nur Indonesia, believes one of the points that needs to be highlighted in the revision of Law No. 7/2017 on Elections is the distribution of seats in the House of Representatives (DPR) based on population size. Because of this, he said, regions with large populations obtain more seats than regions with small populations.
According to him, this will cause problems because seat allocation is not carried out optimally in line with demographic changes. As a result, the value of one vote in one region can differ from that in another region.
“Then, is one seat per region fairer? Not necessarily,” he said.
If all regions received the same number of seats regardless of population size, he assessed that this issue would give rise to injustice. Therefore, Alfath said there needs to be an adjustment in the number of seats contested in one electoral district.
If the number of seats is too small, he said, the relationship between the people’s representative and the voters can indeed be closer. However, the consequence is that the votes of small parties and minority groups, including women, are more difficult to represent.
Conversely, if the number of seats is too large, representation becomes more proportional, but competition between legislative candidates becomes fiercer, political costs increase, and the relationship between the people’s representative and their constituents becomes looser. Thus, Alfath reiterated that the issue is not merely a problem of equalising seat allocation.
“What is more important than this is finding a balanced electoral district magnitude, one that is sufficiently proportional to guarantee representation, yet still maintains closeness and accountability of the people’s representatives to their voters,” he stressed.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ugm-lecturer-highlights-seat-distribution-in-election-law-revision-1781589031)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/900953/dosen-ugm-soroti-distribusi-kursi-dalam-revisi-uu-pemilu), translated from Indonesian