UGM Expert Says Ice Chunk in Bantul Was Not Caused by a Cumulonimbus Cloud
A climatology expert at Gadjah Mada University (UGM) has said that a 20-centimetre-diameter ice chunk which damaged the roof of a house in Jodog, Gilangharjo, Pandak, Bantul, was not formed by a cumulonimbus cloud. The UGM expert also discussed the possibility that it had formed through icing on an aircraft.
“If what is meant is that it came from a cumulonimbus, it seems unlikely,” UGM climatology expert Dr Emilya Nurjani said when contacted by detikJogja on Tuesday (3 November 2026).
According to the Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics Agency (BMKG), a cumulonimbus is a convective cloud that towers high into the sky. In shape, it resembles a mushroom, with a cap-like formation at the top.
In tropical areas, these clouds can reach heights of more than 18 kilometres and may penetrate the stratosphere, a phenomenon usually referred to as a cumulonimbus overshooting top.
Seen from the ground, cumulonimbus clouds appear thick, dark and tall. They can bring extreme weather, heavy rain, lightning and strong winds.
A single-cell cumulonimbus cloud has a life cycle of around 30 to 60 minutes, while multi-cell or supercell cumulonimbus clouds can last longer.
Regarding the suspected cause of the ice chunk that fell on the Pandak resident’s home, one possibility raised was icing — ice accumulating on an aircraft and then breaking off. Emilya said this would require in-depth investigation.
“If it was icing from an aircraft, data would need to be checked to establish whether a plane flew over the area at the time,” she said.
However, Jodog hamlet head Bayu Yunarko said no aircraft had passed over Jodog when the incident occurred. He said the weather was cloudy but there was no rain.
“No plane passed overhead when it happened; it was just overcast,” Bayu told detikJogja today.
Bayu also said there was no ice factory in Jodog, making it likely that the ice chunk had come from above.
“There is no ice factory, and there were no strong winds when it happened,” he said.
The mysterious ice chunk fell onto the roof of a resident’s home in Jodog, Gilangharjo, Pandak, Bantul, at 8am on Monday (2 November). It punched a hole in the roof of the living room.
“The damaged area of the living-room roof measures one by one metre. There were no casualties or injuries, as the house was empty,” said Ribut Bimo Haryo Tejo, secretary of the Bantul Regency Disaster Management Agency (BPBD), when contacted by detikJogja on Monday (2 November).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ugm-expert-says-ice-chunk-in-bantul-was-not-caused-by-a-cumulonimbus-cloud-1793703101)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8736667/pakar-ugm-sebut-bongkahan-es-di-bantul-bukan-gegara-awan-cumulonimbus), translated from Indonesian