Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

UGM Expert Explains the Difference Between Expert Advisers and Special Advisers at Former Religious Affairs Minister Yaqut’s Trial

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
UGM Expert Explains the Difference Between Expert Advisers and Special Advisers at Former Religious Affairs Minister Yaqut’s Trial
Image: detikcom

Richo Andi Wibowo, a state administrative law expert from Gadjah Mada University (UGM), explained the difference between expert advisers and special advisers at ministerial level. He said special advisers do not have the authority to make strategic decisions.

Richo gave the explanation after prosecutors called him as an expert witness in the trial over alleged corruption involving additional Hajj quotas in 2023–2024 at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court on Wednesday (21 October 2026). He said special advisers are attached to the leader they serve.

“Within government, or at ministry level, there are special advisers and expert advisers. Could you explain what is meant by a special adviser or an expert adviser under the relevant laws and regulations, particularly those governing ministries?” a prosecutor asked.

“An expert adviser refers to a position that may be held by someone from within the organisation, Sir. They are a civil servant in that public body who, because of their seniority, experience and breadth of perspective, may be asked to serve as an expert adviser,” Richo said.

He said special advisers had a more flexible role and could be selected from outside the institution. This meant they might not be employees of the government institution.

“Special advisers, by contrast, are attached to the leader and their role is more fluid. They may be selected from outside, although people from within are also eligible. In practice, however, they are often outsiders attached to the leader. They are not part of the ministry or institution’s permanent staff. Their general function is to support the leader,” he said.

Richo said special advisers provide support in the form of advice and perspectives, and are people close to the leader.

“From what you have observed, are special advisers generally, so to speak, people close to the leader?” the prosecutor asked.

“That is right. If someone is not a permanent employee but joins the institutional structure as a special adviser, and the appointment is based on the official’s preference, it is logical that the person selected would be someone close to them,” Richo replied.

The prosecutor then asked about special advisers’ authority. Richo said they were not empowered to make strategic decisions.

“A leader may have several special advisers, each with their own title or designation. But the main point is that they are not in a position to make strategic decisions. They are attached to the leader and provide advice and support,” he said.

The prosecutor asked whether appointments to either expert adviser or special adviser positions were decided by the leader of the institution. Richo agreed that this was the logical arrangement.

In this case, former Religious Affairs Minister Yaqut Cholil Qoumas is accused of causing state losses of Rp622,090,207,166.41 (about Rp622 billion) in the alleged corruption case involving additional Hajj quotas for 2023–2024. Prosecutors said Yaqut acted together with Asrul Azis Taba, chairman of the Kesthuri Association; Yaqut’s former special adviser, Ishfah Abidal Azis, also known as Gus Alex; and Ismail Adham, operations director of PT Makassar Toraja (Maktour).

More from 21 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ugm-expert-explains-the-difference-between-expert-advisers-and-special-advisers-at-former-religious-affairs-1792579963)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8717688/pakar-ugm-jelaskan-beda-staf-ahli-dan-khusus-di-sidang-eks-menag-yaqut), translated from Indonesian
Print