UGM Climatologist Comments on Ice Chunk That Crashed Through Bantul Resident’s Roof
A climatology expert at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), Dr Emilya Nurjani, has commented on an incident in which a 20-centimetre-diameter chunk of ice fell and damaged the roof of a resident’s house in Jodog, Gilangharjo, Pandak, Bantul. The incident happened on Monday.
“If what is meant is that it came from a cumulonimbus cloud, it seems not,” Emilya told detikJogja by telephone on Tuesday (3 November 2026).
Asked about the possibility that the chunk came from aircraft icing — ice that had formed on and then fallen from an aircraft — Emilya said the matter required thorough investigation.
“If it was icing from an aircraft, data would need to be checked to establish whether a plane flew over the area at the time,” she said.
Separately, Jodog hamlet head Bayu Yunarko said no aircraft had flown over Jodog when the ice chunk hit the house. He also confirmed that it was not raining at the time.
“No aircraft passed overhead when it happened; it was just overcast,” Bayu told detikJogja by telephone on Tuesday (3 November 2026).
Bayu said there was no ice factory in Jodog either. He suspected the ice chunk had come from above.
“There is no ice factory, and there were no strong winds when it happened,” he said.
Galvalume roof and ceiling damaged
The mysterious ice chunk fell onto a resident’s house in Jodog, Gilangharjo, Pandak, Bantul, at 8am on Monday (2 November).
“That’s right, a resident’s roof in Jodog was damaged by a falling chunk of ice,” said Ribut Bimo Haryo, secretary of the Bantul Regency Regional Disaster Management Agency (BPBD), when contacted by detikJogja on Monday (2 November 2026).
The incident was discovered by a Jodog resident, Petrus, who was sitting in a gazebo at the home of his younger sibling, Veronica Suharti. He heard a loud bang from inside the house.
“The witness then checked and found a 20-centimetre-diameter chunk of ice had fallen onto the roof of the living room,” Ribut said.
The impact broke the sand-coated galvalume roofing, the PVC ceiling and its frame, as well as a wooden chair. The house was unoccupied at the time.
“The damaged section of the living-room roof measured one metre by one metre. There were no deaths or injuries because the house was empty,” Ribut said.
Ribut said the homeowner, Veronica, was staying in Cilacap, Central Java. Residents had contacted her about the incident.
The BPBD has visited the site. Ribut said he could not yet explain where the ice chunk came from.
“We have informed the Yogyakarta Special Region BMKG so that the phenomenon can be investigated further,” he said.
BMKG comments
The Jogja Meteorological Station said the ice chunk that damaged the house in Pandak fell when it was not raining. There was also a potential spatial disturbance from the Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO) over Java, but further analysis is needed to establish whether it was connected to the ice.
“According to our radar data, there was no rain at the time. Rain in Pandak began at 9am and was light,” said Heri, an on-duty forecaster at the Jogja Meteorological Station, when contacted by detikJogja on Monday (2 November 2026).
Heri said that the morning radar analysis did show rain clouds, but they were located to the north-west, around Pajangan, and to the north, around Panggungharjo in Sewon — not at the site of the incident.
“Therefore, they were not at the location in question,” he said.
Heri added that the BMKG’s preliminary weather analysis had identified a potential spatial MJO disturbance over Java, but this could not yet be confirmed as the cause of the ice chunk falling in Pandak.
“The spatial MJO phenomenon covered Java. The incident was local, so more detailed analysis is needed. Since this specific event happened at just one house in Pandak, more detailed data will be needed to determine where the ice came from,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ugm-climatologist-comments-on-ice-chunk-that-crashed-through-bantul-residents-roof-1793746243)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8737201/kata-pakar-klimatologi-ugm-soal-bongkahan-es-jebol-atap-rumah-warga-bantul), translated from Indonesian