Two Judges' Dissenting Opinion: Ibam, Former Consultant to Nadiem, Should Have Been Acquitted
Former consultant to the Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, Ibrahim Arief alias Ibam, was sentenced to four years in prison in the alleged corruption case concerning the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM). Two out of five judges expressed a differing opinion or dissenting opinion in the imposition of the verdict.
Ibam’s sentencing hearing was held at the Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (12/5/2026). The judges issuing the dissenting opinion were Member Judge II Eryusmas and Member Judge IV Andi Saputra. Meanwhile, the other three judges found Ibam guilty and sentenced him to four years in prison.
“Having considered that for this reason, Member Judge II, Eryusmas, and Member Judge IV, Andi Saputra, conclude that the defendant clearly does not meet all the elements charged by the prosecutor, so he should be acquitted of all charges. Having considered that since the defendant must be acquitted, he is also entitled to the restoration of honour and dignity to his former position, which includes the right to be forgotten,” stated Judge Andi Saputra when reading the dissenting opinion.
The judges stated that Ibam provided general input and did not direct towards a specific brand. The judges opined that Ibam’s input was twisted by the technical team from the Ministry of Education.
“The defendant’s input was cut or twisted by the technical team from the Ministry of Education, so there are many prominent differences between the specifications suggested by the defendant and the specifications in the review study document and Ministry of Education Regulation 05 of 2021,” said the judge.
The judges opined that Ibam provided input on the weaknesses of Chromebooks to Nadiem Makarim on 21 February 2020. The judges also opined that Ibam continued to provide input to re-evaluate prices by the Ministry of Education, suggesting that the ministry conduct a Request for Information (RFI) to distributors to validate prices for competitiveness.
“This shows that the defendant’s capacity was only as an information technology consultant and not a price or financial consultant. And this is common in consulting practices as long as no collusion is found between the consultant and the goods provider, which in this case has not been proven that the defendant engaged in malicious conspiracy or unlawful acts with the principal distributor or reseller,” said the judge.
The judges opined that it was not proven that Ibam conducted business lobbying or approaches to the Ministry of Education’s budget managers to select Chromebooks. The judges stated that Ibam’s meetings with several people from Google were conducted openly and not from personal initiative, but following directions from Nadiem.
“The defendant did not receive kickbacks from the principal so that his analysis and study directed towards a specific brand. In addition, witnesses from the principal side at the trial also stated that they never met the defendant during the laptop procurement project process,” he said.
Furthermore, the judges opined that Ibam’s income of Rp 163 million was legitimate salary for his services as a consultant at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology. The judges stated that there was no mens rea or malicious intent from Ibam in this procurement.
The judges also opined that there was no material or immaterial benefit received by Ibam in this procurement. The judges stated that Ibam’s wealth increase of Rp 16.922,945,800 was from the sale of Bukalapak shares obtained by Ibam while still working at Bukalapak and not connected or affiliated with this case.
“Having considered that therefore, the judge concludes that the defendant, as a consultant, in providing advice to the ministry, neutrally gave considerations on the advantages and disadvantages of selecting a product, and the authority to choose the advisory options presented lies with the ministry,” he concluded.
Previously, Ibam was sentenced to four years in prison. The judges stated that Ibam was guilty in the alleged corruption case of Chromebook and Chrome Device Management (CDM) procurement.
Ibam was fined Rp 500 million. If the fine is not paid, it will be replaced with imprisonment for 120 days.
The judges stated that Ibam was guilty of violating Article 3 in conjunction with Article 18 of the Corruption Offences Law in conjunction with Article 55 paragraph 1 number 1 of the old Criminal Code.
This verdict is much lighter than the prosecutors’ demand. Previously, Ibam was demanded 15 years in prison, a fine of Rp 1 billion subsidiary 190 days imprisonment. The prosecutors also demanded that Ibam pay restitution of Rp 16.92 billion subsidiary 7 years and 6 months imprisonment.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/two-judges-dissenting-opinion-ibam-former-consultant-to-nadiem-should-have-been-acquitted-1778608514)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8486582/2-hakim-dissenting-opinion-ibam-eks-konsultan-nadiem-harusnya-dibebaskan), translated from Indonesian