Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

TV contributions

| Source: The Jakarta Post

TV contributions

The explanation given last week by Jakarta's military
commander Maj. Gen. Sutiyoso, about the use of Bakorstanasda
personnel to help state TV networks collect compulsory
"contributions" from TV owners, may satisfy some people. We
doubt, however, that the commander's statement sounds either very
convincing or very reassuring to most.

Bakorstanasda Jaya, by the way, is the coordinating body in
charge of ensuring stability in the capital city and comprises
top-ranking officials from both the civilian administration and
the military.

According to Sutiyoso, as reported by newspapers, the measure
was in no way meant to intimidate recalcitrant TV set owners.
Rather, it was only to facilitate collection of the monthly
duties, or "contributions", which TV owners are required to make
under current regulations.

The step was taken, Sutiyoso explained, at the request of the
information ministry's director-general of radio, television and
film and was meant to ensure the personal security of the duty
collectors. There was no need to feel apprehensive, since, after
all, both Bakorstanasda and the Jakarta military command were
used to getting requests for protection from both individuals and
institutions.

We see no reason at this point to doubt Gen. Sutiyoso's
agreeable intentions. Still, whatever the purpose, it should be
easy to understand that the inclusion of an agency such as
Bakorstanasda in the collection of the duties is bound to
introduce an element of intimidation.

True, for whatever reasons, many television owners have in the
past been reluctant to comply with the regulations and refused to
pay their contributions.

So far, there has not been a single report of duty collectors
being attacked, or even harassed or threatened, by TV owners.
Although it is true that television owners have consistently
balked paying their monthly contributions.

Several approaches have been tried by the government to
encourage people to comply. The state TV network TVRI is clearly
too understaffed to undertake the job by itself. A private
company was assigned to the task and still people balked.

Against such a background it is difficult to blame people for
getting the distinct impression that the involvement of
Bakorstanasda is meant for no other purpose than to coerce
people into paying.

Such a view is expressed even by legislators in the Jakarta
City Council. Council member Achmad Suaidy, for example, has said
that rather than resorting to such compulsive methods, TVRI needs
to persuade tax payers by regularly giving a public account of
the money it has collected and spent.

The public's reluctance to pay, according to Suaidy, has been
caused by the fact that TVRI has so far shown no evidence of
improving its programs -- which is the stated objective of
collecting the contributions. Using military personnel in the
operation, according to the legislator, would only add to the
community's negative perception.

We find it difficult to disagree. All the more so after the
ill-advised (but wisely aborted) plans to arm district and
subdistrict heads in Surabaya with tear gas and other equipment.
What is most worrying to many people in these instances is our
increasing tendency, whether real or perceived, toward the use of
force to solve problems.

It is to be hoped that the authorities can come up with a more
suitable plan. Or, if those television contributions really prove
impossible to collect, other alternatives could be found, such as
slapping a one-off lump sum duty on the purchase of a TV.

Better still, in this age of technology and modern
communications, serious thought could be given to disposing of
the contributions altogether.

More from 19 August 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tv-contributions-1447893297-1545335)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print