Trump's Trade Tariffs Face New Lawsuit from 25 US States
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — A coalition of 25 US states led by the Democratic Party has officially sued the administration of US President Donald Trump, on Monday local time. The lawsuit alleges that Trump “exceeded the limits of his authority” by imposing massive import tariffs on goods from 60 American trading partners.
The legal action, filed at the US Court of International Trade, challenges tariffs of 10 or 12.5 per cent on most imported goods. According to data from the plaintiff states, the tariff policy affects 99.4 per cent of total US imports.
The plaintiffs urged the court to immediately halt the tariff policy and declare it illegal, and ordered refunds of duties already paid by businesses.
It should be noted that the 10 or 12.5 per cent tariff policy was issued on 24 July under Section 301 of the 1974 Trade Act, relating to combating forced labour. These tariffs replaced earlier reciprocal tariffs — which cited the 1977 International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) — struck down by the Supreme Court in February 2026.
“After losing at the Supreme Court, the administration is once again attempting to illegally raise taxes on families and businesses with a new round of tariffs,” said New York Attorney General Letitia James.
At the heart of the lawsuit is the Trump administration’s effort to preserve its global tariff regime. The states argue that White House officials exploited Section 301 of the 1974 Trade Act merely to recreate import duties nearly identical to those previously struck down by the Supreme Court.
Rushed process
Meanwhile, the lawsuit accuses US Trade Representative (USTR) Jamieson Greer of rushing the investigation into the 60 economies. The new tariffs were finalised in just two and a half months.
The USTR is accused of ignoring country-specific consultation obligations and of failing to explain why nearly uniform tariffs were deemed appropriate for countries with vastly different economic policies. The filing also notes the USTR set no benchmarks for removing duties on affected countries.
“There is no rational connection between alleged forced labour problems in international supply chains and the sweeping global tariffs imposed by the USTR,” the lawsuit states.
The suit also highlights irregularities in the timing of the tariff implementation. The USTR announced the new policy on 23 July, just one day before temporary duties imposed under Section 122 were due to expire.
“This move is seen as a blatant manoeuvre to allow the Trump tariff regime to continue without interruption,” it adds.
Furthermore, the court filing points to several exemptions that undermine the government’s logic. For example, the USTR cited frozen beef from Brazil as one of three examples of goods linked to forced labour, yet curiously that product was exempted from the tariffs.
“This is a tax on hard-working families that will drive up the cost of food, household essentials, building materials and other everyday goods,” said New York Governor Kathy Hochul.
Previously, the US Supreme Court ruled that the IEEPA did not authorise Trump’s earlier tariff regime. The trade court also rejected the government’s use of Section 122, although that ruling is currently stayed pending appeal.
The lawsuit from 25 states is the second legal challenge to the new duties; a similar suit was previously filed by small business groups.
White House response
The White House firmly rejected the arguments, claiming the tariffs were imposed after accusing dozens of countries and the European Union of failing to prevent goods produced with forced labour from entering their supply chains.
“The United States is using its legitimate authority to secure the elimination of unreasonable actions, policies and practices that burden US commerce. Foreign nations’ failure to enforce bans on the importation of goods made with forced labour is unreasonable and burdens US commerce, including American workers, and must be addressed,” said White House Spokesperson Kush Desai.
“Section 301 tariffs have proven to be a durable legal instrument since the president’s first term and remain in effect today,” Desai added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/trumps-trade-tariffs-face-new-lawsuit-from-25-us-states-1785826289)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260804073652-4-756259/siap-siap-tarif-dagang-trump-batal-lagi-digugat-25-negara-bagian), translated from Indonesian