Trumponomics Is Making Americans Worse Off — Is Trump’s Support at Risk?
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — The US midterm elections are just days away. Voters across the country will decide the make-up of the House of Representatives and Senate for the coming years, with the results also shaping the political landscape ahead of the next presidential election.
Historical records show that the party occupying the White House tends to lose House seats in midterm elections. In the past 10 presidencies, the president’s party has lost seats in eight midterms. The only exceptions were in 1998 and 2002. Ahead of the 3 November 2026 election, Trump faces a challenge to his popularity.
A Reuters/Ipsos poll completed on 26 October put approval of his performance at 32%, up one percentage point from the previous poll but still close to the lowest level of his second term.
In the same poll, Democratic candidates led Republicans when voters were asked which party they would support in the congressional elections. Among registered voters, 47% backed the Democrats and 36% the Republicans. Among likely voters, the Democrats’ lead was 53% to 44%.
The poll is not an election result and may not reflect outcomes in every constituency. The contests for control of the House and Senate also have different dynamics, since the number and composition of seats being contested are not the same.
For Trump, the midterms are a test of whether Republicans can retain control of Congress. If the Democrats take either chamber, they could strengthen congressional oversight of the administration, including through investigations and budget negotiations.
The large sums flowing into the 2026 elections therefore reflect more than competition between candidates. The results will also determine the balance of power between the White House and Congress for the remainder of Trump’s term.
Public discontent with Trump’s policies
Many Americans are unhappy with what they see as the abrupt introduction of Trump’s policies. Their dissatisfaction may even be greater than during his first term, from 2015 to 2019.
On 22 October, the White House claimed that its economic policies had raised wages and triggered an “economic boom for the working class”.
The US economy is indeed growing strongly, with output forecast to expand at an annualised rate of about 3% in the third quarter.
But many of the people Trump says he is helping are worse off, while wealthier Americans are benefiting.
Among the policies with the greatest political cost are those that have raised everyday living expenses. Trump’s sweeping tariffs have pushed up the cost of consumer goods by about 2%. Yale’s Budget Lab estimates that the tariffs will add an average of US$1,100 to household costs this year.
The war in the Middle East has also sent oil prices higher and is expected to add a further US$1,000 to average household costs by the end of the year.
By contrast, Trump’s flagship tax-and-spending legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, has increased tax refunds by an average of US$340. The law has also created “Trump Accounts”, an effort to broaden stock-market ownership under which eligible newborns can receive US$1,000 to invest in shares.
However, the biggest gains have gone to wealthier Americans through lower taxes. At the same time, the law has tightened access to food stamps, while more than five million Americans have lost Medicaid benefits. Medicaid is the government healthcare programme for low-income people.
The Economist combined estimates of the effects of tariffs, higher petrol prices, and Trump’s tax-and-spending legislation across income groups in 2026. It estimates that Trump’s policies will leave the poorest tenth of US households worse off by almost 3% of their income. These households have average post-tax and transfer income of about US$37,000.
By contrast, the wealthiest tenth, with average post-tax income of nearly US$500,000, are set to gain almost 3%. Middle-income households, with average incomes of about US$100,000, are expected to lose more than US$400. These calculations do not include the impact of decisions made by Republican members of Congress last year and backed by Trump.
Those decisions have helped push up annual premiums for individual health insurance purchased through exchanges by nearly US$800 on average.
Housing costs are another problem for the president. Mortgage rates, partly driven higher by the inflationary effects of the Middle East war, have risen above 7%. This is encouraging existing homeowners to stay put, limiting the supply of new homes and making housing more expensive.
Last year, builders estimated that tariffs on raw materials would add nearly US$11,000 to the cost of a new home. Trump’s immigration crackdown has also contributed to labour shortages. In September, a survey by the US National Association of Home Builders found that labour costs had risen 4.2% from a year earlier.
Low- and middle-income voters are bearing the greatest impact. In May 2026, first-time home sales fell 5.4% year on year, even as sales of luxury homes rose 6.2%, according to online property company Zillow.
Healthcare and social assistance have accounted for nearly all private-sector job growth since January 2025, as they meet demand from an ageing US population.
The AI boom has been a bright spot, with data-centre investment creating around 180,000 new jobs in industries connected to construction. In other sectors, however, private-sector employment has barely changed. Annual wage growth across the private sector has slowed from 4% to 3%; rising inflation means workers’ hourly pay is 0.7% lower in real terms than a year ago.
Labour’s share of output in non-farm businesses has fallen to its lowest level since records began in 1947.
A revival in manufacturing employment has proved especially elusive. Although manufacturing output has risen, the sector has lost around 20,000 jobs since January 2025, while factory workers’ wages have failed to keep pace with inflation over the past year.
In North Carolina, which Trump won in 2024 and which now appears likely to elect a Democrat to the Senate, nearly 9,000 manufacturing jobs have been lost over the past year.
US stock-market investors may have more reason to celebrate, as the AI boom has lifted technology shares in the S&P 500. But the gains have been uneven. Of the US$17 trillion increase in Americans’ holdings of equities and mutual funds since the end of 2024, nearly 90% went to the wealthiest tenth of households, compared with just 0.6% for the poorest half, according to Federal Reserve data.
The trend has not gone unnoticed. Nearly two-thirds of Americans think Trump’s economic policies have made conditions worse.
The same is true of 35% of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, according to a recent Pew Research Centre poll — nearly twice the share recorded in January.
Voters particularly exposed to higher fuel costs and tariffs, such as farmers, are inclined to shift towards the Democrats.
In an effort to retain voters’ support, Trump has begun promising US$5,000 to every adult citizen if Republicans retain control of Congress on 3 November. But that is unlikely to do much to persuade voters who still feel left behind.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/trumponomics-is-making-americans-worse-off-is-trumps-support-at-risk-1793526651)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20261101145831-128-781261/trumponomics-bikin-warga-as-makin-sengsara-suara-trump-terancam), translated from Indonesian