Trump Loses to Harvard, Judge Dismisses Lawsuit
The administration of US President Donald Trump has suffered another legal defeat in its battle with Harvard University. Federal Judge Richard G. Stearns in Massachusetts on Thursday (13/8/2026) rejected the US government’s lawsuit accusing Harvard of violating civil rights law by failing to protect Jewish and Israeli students from discrimination and harassment on campus.
In a four-page ruling, Stearns granted Harvard’s motion to dismiss the case. The judge concluded that the government had not sufficiently alleged facts to support the claim that violations of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act 1964 were still ongoing at Harvard when the lawsuit was filed on 20 March 2026.
“The court begins, and ends, with Harvard’s first argument,” Stearns wrote. In essence, he said, the government had not sufficiently shown an ongoing violation of Title VI.
The ruling is the latest blow to the Trump administration in its feud with Harvard. However, Stearns’ decision has an important limitation: the court did not declare that antisemitism never occurred at Harvard, nor did it conclude that all allegations of mistreatment of Jewish and Israeli students after the Hamas attack on 7 October 2023 were unfounded.
What the court rejected was the claim that the facts in the lawsuit were sufficient to show that Harvard’s institutional non-compliance with Title VI was still ongoing when the case was brought to court.
Title VI prohibits discrimination based on race, colour, or national origin in programmes and activities receiving federal financial assistance. The law does not explicitly mention religion. However, the federal government applies it to discrimination experienced by Jewish students when that discrimination relates to race, national origin, or shared ancestry or ethnic characteristics.
In the Harvard case, Stearns noted that the government’s complaint focused almost entirely on events during the 2023-2024 academic year, when Harvard’s campus and several US universities became arenas for large demonstrations related to Israel’s war in Gaza.
Only three incidents were cited as occurring after that period. All took place in March 2025, nearly a year before the lawsuit was filed and more than one academic year earlier.
Stearns said he did not intend to diminish concern about those incidents. However, according to the judge, whether viewed individually or collectively, the incidents were “too isolated and episodic” to support a reasonable conclusion that institutional non-compliance with Title VI was still ongoing at Harvard.
Reuters, AP, CBS News and The Wall Street Journal all identified this issue as the crux of the ruling: the government failed to demonstrate ongoing civil rights violations.
Chronology proved to be a decisive factor. On 30 June 2025, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) gave Harvard formal notice of Title VI violation findings. Before taking certain enforcement actions under the law, the government must notify the funding recipient of non-compliance and determine that compliance cannot be obtained voluntarily.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/trump-loses-to-harvard-judge-dismisses-lawsuit-1786665067)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tjq1yw451/trump-kalah-lawan-harvard-hakim-tolak-gugatan), translated from Indonesian