Trapped in a Security Dilemma, US-Iran Ceasefire Becomes Netanyahu's Political Nightmare
The ceasefire agreement between the United States and Iran has now transformed into a political nightmare for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. This decision is seen as destroying three main pillars of Netanyahu’s political career while trapping him in a complex new security dilemma, just months before Israel’s general elections.
How is it possible that a leader who has long portrayed himself as the most capable of ‘steering’ Washington is now being openly sidelined by his primary ally? Furthermore, Netanyahu, who made resistance against Iran the centre of his security policy, must now witness Tehran emerging from this conflict in a position that could be described as stronger.
The choices facing Netanyahu currently are entirely unfavourable. Israel’s opposition leader, Yair Lapid, summarised the situation before the Knesset (Israeli Parliament): “The choice is between direct and destructive confrontation with our greatest ally, or surrendering submissively to Israel’s interests.”
Sharp criticism from US President Donald Trump, who stated that Netanyahu lacked good judgement when ordering attacks in Beirut, has been directly utilised by his political rivals. Moreover, right-wing allies within his own coalition cabinet are beginning to exert heavy pressure, particularly regarding Iran’s demand that this ceasefire include the cessation of military operations on all fronts, including Lebanon.
Israel’s right-wing National Security Minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, affirmed his rejection on social media: “Trump’s deal does not bind us. We are not part of an agreement that does not guarantee our security.”
On the other hand, Likud party MP Ariel Kallner stated, “Israel will continue to protect itself.” However, he was reluctant to detail whether this means attacks will continue. “We will do what we need to do. And we hope our friends understand us,” he added.
Former Mossad official and Iran specialist, Sima Shine, also questioned the US stance. “It is difficult to understand why America accepts it. By allowing Iran to determine what will happen in Lebanon, the US is giving Iran the opportunity to continue supporting Hezbollah, and ensuring Hezbollah remains a key political actor in the Lebanese arena. Israel is not happy with this – neither the security nor the political institutions,” she remarked.
Until now, the security narrative has always been Netanyahu’s primary asset for attracting voters. Following the attacks of 7 October 2023, he shifted Israel’s security policy to be more aggressive, based on the principle of cutting off threats directly rather than merely containing them.
However, despite the Israeli military having destroyed much of Gaza and killed over 73,000 people according to the Hamas-run health ministry, the group effectively still controls half of the territory and is beginning to reassert its power. This new approach has also forced Israeli forces to occupy vast areas of Gaza, Lebanon, and Syria, which is now beginning to drain Israel’s military resources and reserves to a critical point without a clear diplomatic path.
Senior analyst for Iranian affairs at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), Danny Citrinowicz, assessed that Israel must reformulate its strategy. “Any Israeli military action that Washington considers an attempt to sabotage the agreement is expected to face a harsh response from the US,” he wrote in the Israeli daily Hayom.
He added that, unlike the Obama era, the options for Netanyahu to bypass the White House by rallying support in Congress are now almost non-existent. Netanyahu’s political promise of being the best protector against regional threats now appears to be being refuted by the realities on the ground.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/trapped-in-a-security-dilemma-us-iran-ceasefire-becomes-netanyahus-political-nightmare-1781560226)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/internasional/900858/terjebak-dilema-keamanan-gencatan-senjata-as-iran-jadi-mimpi-buruk-politik-netanyahu), translated from Indonesian