Transfer of Ex-Jampidsus Febrie Adriansyah's Case File to AGO Deemed Tactical and Practical
Jakarta, VIVA – Political and legal analyst Boni Hargens has assessed the handover of the case file on the alleged coal corruption scandal implicating former Deputy Attorney General Febrie Adriansyah, transferred from the National Police (Polri) to the Attorney General’s Office (Kejagung), as a tactical and practical step to prevent an institutional clash.
Boni explained that the National Police’s move was a rational institutional response, namely a mechanism to avoid a collision between law enforcement agencies that could harm the enforcement of the law as a whole.
“In this context, the interest of maintaining institutional harmony between the National Police and the Attorney General’s Office is considered more pressing than rigid procedural compliance. This difference in perspective reflects the classic tension between formal legality and practical effectiveness within the Indonesian legal system,” Boni said in a statement on Thursday, 16 July 2026.
According to Boni, the difference between handing over a case file and submitting a completed investigation file (penyerahan berkas kelanjutan penyidikan) is not merely semantic, but concerns jurisdiction, legal responsibility, and the validity of the prosecution process.
Furthermore, Boni explained that there are a number of legal foundations within the Indonesian legal system that can be used to justify the National Police’s decision on juridical grounds.
“The first is Article 14 of Law No. 2 of 2002 (the National Police Law). It stipulates that the National Police holds discretionary authority in determining investigative priorities and strategies, including cross-agency coordination for the effective handling of cases, as the basis for the legality of a coordinative handover of case files,” he said.
The second argument is Articles 38–40 of Law No. 16 of 2004 (the Prosecution Service Law). “The prosecution service is authorised to coordinate the investigation and inquiry of certain criminal offences. Therefore, the handover of the file can be construed as coordination between law enforcement agencies within the criminal justice system that is legally valid,” Boni continued.
Within Indonesia’s criminal justice system, the prosecutor acts as the dominus litis, or master of the case. The handover of a file to the prosecution service can be interpreted as a form of involving the prosecutor in the investigative process, which in fact strengthens the legality of any subsequent prosecution.
Boni said the Indonesian criminal justice system prioritises integration between its subsystems, namely the National Police, the Prosecution Service, the Courts, and Prisons.
According to Boni, the strongest argument for the National Police is to frame this handover not as a technical transfer under the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP), but as institutional coordination between law enforcement agencies supported by the National Police Law, the Prosecution Service Law, and the principle of an integrated criminal justice system, so that it is not required to comply with the P21 requirements stipulated in the KUHAP.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/transfer-of-ex-jampidsus-febrie-adriansyahs-case-file-to-ago-deemed-tactical-and-practical-1784220695)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1914111-pelimpahan-berkas-kasus-eks-jampidsus-febrie-adriansyah-ke-kejagung-dinilai-taktis-dan-praktis), translated from Indonesian