Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Toward reconciliation

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Toward reconciliation

Indonesia took a significant step in the right direction
yesterday, with the adoption by the House of Representatives of
the long-awaited Law on Truth and Reconciliation. To be sure, the
new law is not likely to expunge all sources of contention that
have pestered the nation over the past few decades. Hence, many
of the old wounds that were inflicted on millions will continue
to fester, and key events in the country's recent history will no
doubt remain obscured.

But, at least a flicker of hope now exists that some, if not
all, of the wounds can be healed. For example: What, in truth,
happened in those pre-dawn hours of Oct.1, 1965, when thousands
of Communist Party cadres and supporters were said to be roaming
Jakarta's deserted streets, searching out homes in the city's
elite neighborhoods, abducting and killing the Army's top
leadership? So far, all that is known is what the New Order
authorities -- with their recognized and proven penchant for
falsifying historic fact -- claimed happened.

On that grounds -- in part resting on fact, in part on
supposition -- hundreds of thousands of Indonesian were killed on
accusations of harboring or sympathizing with the communist
ideology. An equal number, if not millions, were imprisoned and
possibly tortured, or had their most basic civil rights
curtailed. Only very recently, in this era of democratic reform,
were their and their offspring's right to vote restored, though
not their right to be elected, either to the legislature or to
the presidency.

Authorities in Jakarta are making no bones about the fact that
the Indonesian Truth and Reconciliation Commission -- which
hopefully will be established shortly after the new law has been
signed by the President -- is modeled on the South African truth
and reconciliation commission, which seems to have been quite
successful in laying a solid foundation for maintaining an
atmosphere of peace and social accord in that country. But while
peace and social accord are certainly crucial byproducts of the
commission's work, the purpose of the law is to do so, not so
much by punishing the perpetrators of human rights violations in
the past, as by setting right the course of history and
historiography, to right past wrongs, and to make sure that the
same violations are not repeated in the future.

Admittedly, in its present form, the new Law on Truth and
Reconciliation does not satisfy everyone. Among advocates of
human rights, there are quite a number who feel that the new law
leans too heavily toward the possibility of pardoning past
perpetrators of human rights violations, and not enough toward
rehabilitating and compensating their victims.

Also, while to this day the 1965 massacre remains the biggest
and most abhorrent case of human rights violations in the
nation's history, it is certainly not the only one that needs
attention. Among the most recent and most indelible are the human
rights abuses committed in East Timor -- the most glaring being
the Santa Maria massacre in 1991, and the killings committed in
the aftermath of the independence referendum in 1999.

As we have seen, no one has, so far, been willing to freely
admit responsibility for those two cases. Many observers believe,
the same obstacles are likely to be in the way of the Truth and
Reconciliation Commission, once it is formed. So far, Abdurrahman
"Gus Dur" Wahid has been the only Indonesian of prominence
willing or courageous enough to apologize for having had a part
-- as a member and, later, chairman of the Nahdlatul Ulama (NU)
Muslim organization -- in the 1965 massacre of communists and
communist sympathizers.

Nevertheless, a good start toward righting our collective past
wrongs has been made with the passing of the Law on Truth and
Reconciliation on Tuesday. Hopefully, those who are responsible
will have the courage and the magnanimity to respond suitably,
for the sake of the future of this country and its future
generations.

More from 8 September 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/toward-reconciliation-1447893297-1457597)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print