Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Too Capable to Receive Help, Too Vulnerable to Fall

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Too Capable to Receive Help, Too Vulnerable to Fall
Image: Republika

It is only halfway through the month, yet the bank balance of a private-sector employee is already running very low. Their salary is above the minimum wage; they own a vehicle, rent a home and hold a university degree. On paper, they belong to the middle class: not wealthy enough to live extravagantly, but not considered poor either. As payday approaches, they are haunted by their dwindling balance. They are not spending lavishly; far from splashing out, they are working hard to make the sums add up.

They calculate every expense as carefully as if competing in an Olympiad, trying to cover all their needs with a salary that barely stretches far enough. This picture may sound fictional. But amid the recent popularity of “situations you may recognise” trends, it feels remarkably close to the reality around us.

Statistics Indonesia (BPS) data show that the number of Indonesians in the middle class fell from 57.33 million in 2019 to 47.85 million in 2024. The decline has continued. Mandiri Institute estimates that the middle class remained on a downward trend in 2025. Meanwhile, the group on the verge of entering the middle class has swelled to 142 million people—half of Indonesia’s population. More people are at risk of slipping into the lower class, while moving up the economic ladder is becoming increasingly difficult.

The middle class plays a major role in the economy, accounting for about 82 per cent of national consumption. Yet the quality of its employment is also under pressure. The proportion of middle-class workers employed in the formal sector fell from 61.71 per cent in 2019 to 58.65 per cent in 2023. These figures are not merely statistics; they reflect the growing fragility of middle-class households.

Social protection has traditionally been designed for poor households. Such policies are essential and should be maintained. The problem arises when middle-income households face economic pressure without adequate protection. As a result, they have almost no schemes or policies specifically designed for them. CNBC Indonesia, for example, cited CORE researcher Yusuf Rendy Manilet as saying that social protection policies still largely target poor households.

When value-added tax (VAT) rose to 11 per cent in 2022, he said, there was no additional assistance specifically for the middle class. Yet financial pressure can strike at any time: through redundancy, rising prices for basic necessities or soaring education costs, while the support available to middle-class households remains uncertain. Assistance only becomes available once a family has fallen too far down the economic ladder, when what it needs is a handhold before it falls further.

Several economists have therefore called for social safety nets and public services to be expanded to cover the middle class. The government has also said it would help this group on the basis of an assessment. But what kind of assessment? And will workers whose time is consumed by their jobs be able to access it easily?

The problem is evident in the system used to identify assistance recipients. The government distributes aid through the National Single Socio-Economic Data system (DTSEN), a database underpinning social protection programmes. It divides the population into ten deciles according to socio-economic circumstances. Social assistance is prioritised for deciles one to four, covering the 40 per cent of the population at the bottom of the economic scale. Deciles six to ten are outside the main priority group for various assistance programmes.

The problem is that decile rankings rely on data that do not always keep pace with changes in people’s lives. Someone’s economic circumstances can change faster than the data are updated. A person who has just lost their job, taken on substantial loan repayments or become responsible for caring for a sick parent may suffer a sharp decline in their ability to pay, but this may not be reflected in the records straight away. This is where a gap emerges between someone’s actual circumstances and what is recorded on paper or in the database.

A similar issue arises with access to scholarships. Under the 2026 KIP Kuliah guidelines, one of the indicators used to determine eligibility relates to a student’s welfare decile in DTSEN. Higher-decile groups are not a priority. Prospective students who are not listed in DTSEN can still apply and may qualify, provided they meet certain requirements and submit supporting documents to demonstrate their financial circumstances.

This often creates an irony. Middle-class families are considered sufficiently well-off not to be a priority for assistance, but if they want to access support, they must prove again that their financial circumstances are in fact precarious.

The process can also be exhausting. People whose decile does not reflect their actual circumstances are advised to seek an update through their village or urban ward office, or the Social Affairs Office. Those who are not registered must put themselves forward through a village meeting, bringing their identity card (KTP) and family card (KK). For workers with long hours and a registered family address that differs from where they live, this is hardly something that can be sorted out overnight. Assistance may also fail to reach them simply because their address cannot be found in the data. The administrative burden ultimately falls on citizens, rather than on the state, which should be responsible for ensuring the data are accurate.

Meanwhile, household expenses continue to rise. Economist Piter Abdullah says the middle class is in a difficult position: it is not a primary target of social assistance, yet faces numerous payment obligations. CELIOS economist Bhima Yudhistira has also highlighted the cumulative costs borne by middle-class households, including Tapera housing-savings contributions, BPJS Health premiums, education costs and various other levies and financing policies. Each may have its own rationale, but when they accumulate, the burden is still felt by households in the middle.

The government has a legitimate argument that deserves consideration. Assistance must first reach those at the bottom of the economic ladder, and Social Affairs Minister Saifullah Yusuf has noted that some people also move up the income scale. That is true. State resources are limited, and this is a reason to design assistance more intelligently—not an excuse to look away. The middle class continued to shrink through 2025, and prioritising those at the bottom does not mean allowing those just above them to fall without support.

Several measures are worth considering. First, make data updates proactive: the state should carry out checks and update records, rather than requiring citizens to queue up to prove their circumstances. Second, assess eligibility for assistance and scholarships using not only decile rankings but also actual pressures, such as the number of dependants, education costs and job loss. Third, establish additional layers of protection that do not depend on being labelled poor, such as unemployment insurance, retraining and tiered reductions in education costs. Fourth, assess the cumulative impact of contributions and levies on middle-income households.

A state is measured not only by how many people it helps lift out of poverty, but also by how effectively it prevents people from falling into it. The private-sector employee may still have to recalculate next month’s spending. If policy only blames them for how they manage their money and requires them to prove they are poor enough to receive help, they are not failing alone.

More from 9 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/too-capable-to-receive-help-too-vulnerable-to-fall-1791550300)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/786511/terlalu-mampu-untuk-dibantu-terlalu-rentan-untuk-jatuh), translated from Indonesian
Print