Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

TNI Deputy Commander Responds to Constitutional Court Ruling: ‘Our Sentences Are Tougher’

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
TNI Deputy Commander Responds to Constitutional Court Ruling: ‘Our Sentences Are Tougher’
Image: CNN Indonesia

TNI Deputy Commander General Maruli Simanjuntak has responded to the Constitutional Court’s ruling, which granted in full a judicial review petition challenging Law No. 31 of 1997 on Military Courts.

One point in the ruling states that TNI personnel who commit ordinary criminal offences must be tried in civilian courts.

Maruli claimed that military courts have often imposed what he described as harsher sentences than civilian courts. He rejected the view that military courts have fostered impunity for TNI personnel.

“In fact, if you compare many cases, we have also been tougher in many criminal cases. In the military, there have been repeated cases of life imprisonment. I think that is rare elsewhere,” Maruli said at Merdeka Palace in Jakarta on Thursday (15 October).

Maruli said military courts more often handed down heavier sentences than civilian courts.

He said there might be other factors in a trial that could explain why a sentence was considered lighter than the offence committed.

“There may be factors that, if we could follow the trial, would help us understand why an offence like this appears to have taken place, yet the court imposed a lighter sentence. I will look into it in more detail,” he said.

Maruli said he would study the Constitutional Court’s ruling more closely and discuss the history of the Military Courts Law.

One point in Decision No. 260/PUU-XXIII/2025 states that TNI personnel who commit ordinary criminal offences must be tried in civilian courts. In the case, the Constitutional Court granted in full the petition for judicial review of the Military Courts Law.

The Court said lawmakers had up to two years to amend the law.

In its reasoning, the Court said that military offences fall under military court jurisdiction because of the offences’ inherent nature. Their elements and unlawful character arise from military status, official duties and obligations, the chain of command, discipline, or legal interests specific to military life.

“This means that assessing such conduct requires not only applying criminal law, but also taking account of an understanding of military life and its structure,” Constitutional Court Justice Arsul Sani said on Thursday (15 October).

More from 16 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tni-deputy-commander-responds-to-constitutional-court-ruling-our-sentences-are-tougher-1792111932)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261016062737-12-1415940/wakil-panglima-tni-respons-putusan-mk-hukuman-kami-lebih-tegas), translated from Indonesian
Print