Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Tiered Administrative Fees on Sharia-Labelled Loans

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Tiered Administrative Fees on Sharia-Labelled Loans
Image: Republika

Recently, there have been increasing options for borrowing money outside of traditional banks. One such option is Savings and Loan Cooperatives (KSP) using a Sharia label, a phenomenon that should be welcomed positively as it expands financial access for those previously unreached by formal banking services.

However, there is one matter that requires close scrutiny. Some of these institutions claim to be free from ‘Riba’ (usury), yet simultaneously impose administrative fees that increase in tandem with the size of the loan. This naturally raises questions: is such a pattern permitted under Islamic law, or does it potentially fall into the category of Riba under a different name? This writing does not intend to blame anyone, but rather invites us to think more clearly about this issue.

What is Qardh and why is it important?

In Islam, a loan is referred to as Qardh. Fundamentally, a loan is intended for mutual assistance (tabarru’), not for profit-seeking (tijarah). This means that anyone lending money must not take any profit simply because they have provided the loan, no matter how small that profit may be.

This is established in a well-known principle of Islamic jurisprudence: “Every loan that brings benefit to the lender is Riba.”

However, it must be understood that scholars do not prohibit all types of fees. Administrative costs that truly reflect actual expenses incurred by the institution—such as document printing costs, verification processes, and so on—are fundamentally permissible, provided the amounts are reasonable and not excessive.

So, what is the problem with administrative fees that rise according to the loan amount?

Consider this: you borrow Rp 3,000,000 and are charged an admin fee of Rp 300,000. Your friend borrows Rp 100,000,000 and is charged an admin fee of Rp 2,000,000. Logically, the administrative process—data entry, verification, printing documents—is roughly the same. Why, then, can the fees differ so significantly?

This is where the question needs an honest answer. Indeed, there are arguments that can defend this pattern: larger loans usually require stricter verification processes, the risk borne by the institution is higher, and the operational responsibility is greater. This argument is logical and cannot be ignored.

On the other hand, if the difference in admin fees is vast while the administrative workload does not differ significantly, we must ask: can the excess fee still be called a legitimate “service fee,” or has it actually become a form of profit derived from the lent money?

This question cannot be answered by looking at the figures alone. It requires a deeper look into the actual real cost structure incurred by the institution.

What does the DSN-MUI Fatwa say?

There is one relevant fatwa for consideration, namely the DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 44/DSN-MUI/VIII/2004 regarding Multi-service Financing. One point states: “The amount of ujrah (fee) must be agreed upon at the beginning and stated in nominal form, not in percentage form.”

Simply put, this fatwa encourages service fees to be fixed from the start in a certain figure that does not change, rather than in a percentage that continues to grow following the transaction value.

When linked to the aforementioned tiered admin fee pattern, it is natural that questions arise as to whether such a pattern aligns with or potentially deviates from the spirit of this fatwa. However, it should be noted that this fatwa was originally intended for the context of multi-service financing, not specifically for loans (Qardh). Therefore, its application requires caution and cannot be generalised.

Hidden Riba: Riba Khafi

Ibnu Qayyim al-Jauziyyah, a classical scholar whose thoughts are still widely referenced today, discussed what he called ‘Riba Khafi’ or hidden riba. This refers to practices that appear legitimate on the surface and do not use the word “interest,” but upon deeper investigation, the substance is problematic according to Sharia.

Thus, administrative fees that follow the loan amount need to be reflected upon within this framework of thought. This does not mean immediately labelling it as Riba Khafi, as reaching such a conclusion requires much deeper analysis: the intention behind the contract, the actual real operational costs incurred, and the real impact felt by the borrower.

This is where the role of the Sharia Supervisory Board (DPS) and researchers in the field of Islamic economics is vital to conduct an objective evaluation.

From everything discussed, there are several points for us to reflect upon together.

First, calling oneself a “Sharia” institution should not just be about a name or a promotional strategy. It is a commitment to truly implement the principles of fair and accountable muamalah (transactions).

Second, the pattern of administrative fees that continuously rise following the loan amount is something that needs more serious study—not to be immediately blamed, but also not to be left without supervision. There is a potential that such a pattern could shift the function of admin fees from what they should be (compensation for actual services) to something resembling profit from debt. And if proven, that is problematic according to Sharia.

Third, the task of academics and Sharia supervisors is not to judge, but to accompany and provide constructive input. The public, too, needs to be continuously educated so as not to be easily enticed by the “Sharia” label without understanding how the institution truly operates.

Ultimately, an ideal Sharia economy is not just about avoiding the word “interest,” but about building a system that is truly fair and does not exploit anyone, especially those who are most in need.

More from 24 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tiered-administrative-fees-on-sharia-labelled-loans-1782280358)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/765999/biaya-administrasi-berjenjang-pada-pinjaman-berlabel-syariah), translated from Indonesian
Print