Three Witnesses Corroborate Money Request in Extortion Case Against Lawyer
JAKARTA — Three witnesses called by prosecutors in the trial of Bangun Paulus Tudungta, who is accused of extortion and making threats, acknowledged that money had been discussed. However, they denied that a hammer and handcuffs were used to threaten the alleged victim, Vincent Leo Carlius.
The testimony was given at a hearing in case No. 399/Pid.B/2026/PN Jkt.Pst at the Central Jakarta District Court on Thursday (8 October 2026). The three witnesses called by prosecutor Andri Saputra were Ari Krisdianto Malega, Philip and Alandra Putra Prihardianto.
They are associates of the defendant and were inside the car when the incident in question took place.
After the hearing, Andri said the witnesses’ accounts were broadly consistent with their statements recorded during the investigation. However, there were differences in some details, particularly the amounts of money and the alleged violence against the victim.
“The main point, in our view as prosecutors, is that money was requested. We respect the differences over the amounts and the alleged violence described by another witness, Vincent, because all the witnesses have sworn an oath. The panel of judges will assess all the testimony,” Andri said.
One difference between the witnesses’ accounts concerned the amount allegedly requested from Vincent. Andri said Ari testified that the figure was Rp50 million, while Philip cited Rp300 million, later reduced to Rp200 million.
Those discrepancies will form part of the evidence to be assessed by the judges alongside other witness testimony and evidence presented at trial.
At an earlier hearing, Vincent said the defendant had initially requested Rp500 million. According to his testimony, the amount changed several times, and he said he eventually transferred Rp22 million.
Despite the differing figures, prosecutors consider the witnesses’ testimony about discussions and a request for money to be an important point in the case. The assessment of all the testimony, however, is for the panel of judges.
The presence of a hammer and handcuffs in the car was also discussed at the hearing. The witnesses acknowledged that the items were there, but denied they had been used to frighten or threaten Vincent.
That account differs from Vincent’s testimony at the previous hearing. He said he had been threatened with a hammer while in the vehicle with the defendant and several other people.
The prosecution acknowledged the conflicting accounts. Andri said his side respected each witness’s testimony, including the disagreement between Vincent and those who had been in the car.
“The judge will assess the alleged violence and everything related to it. Vincent testified that there was violence; they [the witnesses in the car] said there was not. We respect their testimony too, as each has sworn an oath,” Andri said.
Meanwhile, Bangun Paulus’s lawyer, Cuaca Teger Bangun, said the testimony given at trial had rebutted the prosecution’s allegations. He pointed to the witnesses’ denials that a hammer and handcuffs had been used to threaten Vincent.
“They said Paulus was disappointed with the situation,” Cuaca said.
Bangun Paulus himself had little to say when invited to respond by the panel of judges. He asked a few questions and said he respected the witnesses’ testimony in court.
The prosecutor also said another witness could not be brought to court because investigators had never questioned the person and did not know their whereabouts. “From the beginning, investigators could not find AL. We don’t know where they are; they could not be located, and the others had only just met them,” Andri said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/three-witnesses-corroborate-money-request-in-extortion-case-against-lawyer-1791561116)
Originally published by Republika (https://rejogja.republika.co.id/berita/tmncgd320/3-saksi-perkuat-adanya-intimidasi-dalam-kasus-dugaan-pemerasan-oleh-oknum-pengacara), translated from Indonesian