This Indonesian Region Grew Wealthy Without Taxing Its People
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Paying taxes is an obligation that people often complain about. Yet around 244 years ago, people and nobles in one part of what is now Indonesia were said to have been reluctant to pay taxes to their rulers, while still living amid prosperity. That region was Palembang, then one of the richest sultanates in the archipelago.
The story appears in the observations of traveller William Marsden. In History of Sumatra (1966), Marsden noted that the Sultanate of Palembang, under Sultan Baddaruddin, possessed great wealth, although its ruler’s income did not depend on tax levies in the way it did in most kingdoms.
The reluctance of the people and nobles to pay taxes did not leave the sultanate without sources of income. Palembang’s wealth was supported by trade in valuable commodities, particularly pepper and tin.
From the establishment of the Dutch East India Company (VOC) in 1602, Palembang pepper became a prized commodity in global markets as European demand for the spice grew. Historian Barbara W. Andaya, in Hidup Bersaudara: Sumatera Tenggara pada Abad 17–18 (2016), says the VOC was eager to secure pepper-trading contracts with the Sultanate of Palembang.
That ambition eventually enabled the VOC to establish a monopoly over the pepper trade in Palembang. In the process, the sultanate and local pepper traders earned income from the commodity.
The VOC’s monopoly, however, did not ultimately work entirely as intended. People continued to trade beyond the Dutch company’s control, selling pepper to other parties.
Historian M.C. Ricklefs, in Sejarah Indonesia Modern (2004), records that this was because the pepper market had grown sharply. The traders had also come to enjoy the profits from selling pepper.
As well as pepper, Palembang grew wealthy through the tin trade from Bangka. During the colonial period, tin was used to make metal goods and weapons. Sales of tin to the Dutch were said to have reached 1,250 tonnes a year.
The prosperity generated by this trade is also reflected in the account of Alfred Russel Wallace, who visited Palembang in 1861. Wallace saw women and children wearing silver jewellery on several parts of their bodies.
“Their wives and children are adorned with silver bracelets from the wrist to the elbow. They also wear dozens of silver rings around their necks or hanging from their ears,” Wallace wrote in The Malay Archipelago (1869).
The story of the Sultanate of Palembang shows how commodity trading can provide an important source of income for a region. However, these historical accounts do not in themselves prove that prosperity was shared equally among the population, or that the sultanate had no other levies.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/this-indonesian-region-grew-wealthy-without-taxing-its-people-1793263866)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/entrepreneur/20261029141136-25-780591/wilayah-ri-ini-kaya-raya-tanpa-pungut-pajak-dari-rakyat), translated from Indonesian