The US-China Tug of Law
Imagine an international bank facing a difficult choice. The United States government orders it to freeze the assets of a Chinese company subject to sanctions. The bank complies. But then it is sued in a Chinese court precisely for obeying the American order. Which should it obey: American law or Chinese law?
Such a situation is no longer merely a possibility. JPMorgan Chase and Citigroup are now facing lawsuits totalling around US$44 million in China after freezing the assets of a Chinese oil trader under American sanctions. In June, a Chinese court also applied new rules in the case of a Singaporean company that refused to send goods to a Hong Kong company subject to sanctions.
The Economist edition of 29 August 2026 highlighted an interesting development in US-China rivalry with the term ‘tug of law’ (a play on tug of war). Competition that has so far played out through trade, tariffs and technology is now entering another domain. National law is increasingly being used as an instrument of power to influence companies and individuals far beyond a country’s borders.
America’s long arm
America has long possessed this capability. Through economic sanctions and export restrictions, Washington can influence the behaviour of foreign companies that deal with sanctioned countries or companies. This power is made possible chiefly by the central position of the dollar, the American financial system, technology and the sheer size of the US market. For international companies, losing access to all of that can cause enormous damage.
China for years criticised the practice as the extraterritorial use of American law. But now an interesting irony has emerged: after long condemning the long arm of American law, Beijing has begun building its own long arm. This shift has become increasingly visible since 2018, when President Xi Jinping asked Chinese officials to use ‘legal weapons’ befitting China’s status as a great power.
That same year, Meng Wanzhou, a Huawei executive, was arrested in Canada at America’s request in a case related to sanctions against Iran. The incident helped awaken Beijing to the vulnerability of Chinese companies and citizens to the reach of US law. Since 2021, China has been building and strengthening various rules to counter foreign sanctions deemed harmful to Chinese interests.
With these legal instruments, China can now respond to American sanctions not only through diplomatic protests or political action, but also through rules that bind companies. If America prohibits a company from transacting with a sanctioned Chinese entity, China can in certain circumstances prohibit that company from complying with American sanctions. As a result, international companies can face two conflicting legal obligations: complying with one country’s rules can mean violating another country’s rules.
Two sources of power
Interestingly, America and China have different sources of power. America’s long arm is chiefly underpinned by the dollar, the financial system and technology, while China increasingly relies on its manufacturing strength and supply chains. China is now also expanding export controls over certain goods produced abroad but using Chinese components or technology. In certain circumstances, selling such goods to other countries or companies may require a permit from the Chinese government.
The difference in sources of power places global companies in an increasingly complicated position. A company can obtain financing in New York, use American technology, have factories or suppliers in China, and then sell its products around the world. Dependence on both countries means the company can be subject to both American and Chinese rules. When both countries use that dependence as leverage, decisions that were originally commercial can turn into geopolitical matters.
The dispute between Samsung and the Chinese telecommunications company ZTE illustrates this complexity. Courts in London and Chongqing issued different rulings in a licensing dispute between the two companies. Complying with one court’s decision can create problems with the other court’s decision. For Samsung, which has a large market and supply chain in China, the Chinese court’s decision is certainly difficult to ignore.
Not just a corporate matter
This development shows another side of globalisation. Closer economic ties do increase trade and efficiency, but they also create interdependence between countries. In great-power rivalry, that dependence can be used as leverage or a bargaining chip. The dollar, technology, markets and supply chains are therefore no longer merely economic instruments, but can also become sources of political and legal power.
It is in this context that US-China rivalry is now also extending into the legal sphere. America has long used its sanctions and national rules to influence companies beyond its territory, while China is beginning to build similar capabilities. As a result, companies and third countries can face conflicting rules from both countries. For Indonesia, the challenge is to maintain productive economic relations with both, while ensuring that the government and the business community understand and are able to manage the increasingly complex legal risks.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-us-china-tug-of-law-1788137490)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tklw1s393/tarik-tambang-hukum-aschina), translated from Indonesian