The Two Faces of the 2025 PISA Test Results
We should welcome the announcement of the 2025 PISA results, even though they present two different faces. The first face contains optimism, as reading scores rose to 365, a 6-point increase from the 2022 results, and science scores reached 389, also increasing by 6 points. However, the second face contains pessimism, as mathematics scores fell to 364, a 2-point decrease. The 2025 PISA was participated in by 91 countries, more than the 80 countries involved in PISA 2022.
What provides some comfort from these PISA results is that, globally, between 2022 and 2025, the average scores in 35 OECD participant countries fell: mathematics dropped by 9 points (465), reading dropped by 14 points (643), and science dropped by 3 points (484). Although our scores remain much lower when compared to the highest-achieving nations, our reading and science scores have risen. We appreciate the increase in reading and science scores; conversely, we need to closely examine the decline in mathematics scores. It appears that mathematics remains a daunting challenge for Indonesian students.
Based on the 2025 PISA results, we can observe progress in learning within formal schools. However, if we revisit Law No. 59 of 2024 regarding the National Long-Term Development Plan (RPJPN) 2025–2045, which uses average PISA scores as an indicator for social transformation success, the 2025 PISA achievements have missed the baseline data set for the 2045 targets. The baseline data in the RPJPN Law is overly optimistic, setting a reading score of 396 in 2025 to leap to 485, mathematics from 404 in 2025 to 490, and science from 416 in 2025 to 487 by 2045. Setting such high 2025 PISA targets feels almost like a trap, considering the baseline was determined by the previous regime when PISA scores were actually declining.
THE STORY BEHIND THE SCORES
Regardless of the scores achieved, it is interesting to note the comments from Andreas Schleicher, Director for Education and Skills at the OECD. According to Andreas, Indonesia has successfully achieved something that remains a challenge for many countries: increasing access to education without sacrificing quality. Over the last two decades, the education participation rate for 15-year-olds has nearly doubled. Nevertheless, the achievement of 15-year-olds in Indonesia in the OECD PISA test remains relatively stable.
Some of the most encouraging findings from this year’s PISA emerge upon deeper analysis. 15-year-olds in Indonesia demonstrate a level of curiosity that is among the highest, a vital asset in today’s increasingly innovation-driven economy. They have also developed the ability to learn independently. This is crucial because those who succeed in the future will not merely be those with the most knowledge, but those capable of lifelong learning.
The emergence of strong curiosity and the ability to develop independent learning skills in Indonesian children over the age of 15 is the result of a good learning process and serves as capital for broader progress. It is hoped that both will emerge as the fruit of the ‘deep learning’ approach promoted by the Minister of Primary and Secondary Education, Abdul Mu’ti. Deep learning, when understood and applied correctly, will encourage students to ask more questions as an expression of their high curiosity.
Another point noted by Andreas is that Indonesian students show better achievement in computational problem-solving compared to more conventional subjects. Furthermore, compared to students in many other countries, Indonesian students are more frequently engaged in learning how to assess the credibility of content generated by Artificial Intelligence (AI). Amidst a world increasingly influenced by AI, these skills will become essential competencies for various high-end jobs of the future.
The appreciation expressed by Andreas Schleicher is a qualitative assessment that is far more meaningful than quantitative scores. This qualitative assessment reflects significant progress in our learning processes. This may be due to the policy of Minister Abdul Mu’ti to implement coding and AI learning in primary and secondary education.
AS A REFERENCE ONLY
In reality, considering the very small sample size (5,000 students) for a country as vast and geographically, economically, socially, and culturally diverse as Indonesia, the PISA results may not fully reflect the true reality on the ground. In Java, which has many excellent schools, the reality might be far better than the PISA scores. Conversely, in remote areas, particularly the 3T regions (frontier, outermost, and least developed), the reality might be lower than the PISA scores.
This means that, methodologically, it is valid to use PISA test results as a reference to observe national education quality, but only as a reference, not as an absolute guide for national education development. We must continue to develop our own learning models suited to the characteristics of this diverse nation. While targets for improving PISA scores must be pursued, it is far more important to develop learning models that align with our nation’s unique character to provide meaningful education.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-two-faces-of-the-2025-pisa-test-results-1789426280)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/opini/933398/dua-wajah-hasil-tes-pisa-2025), translated from Indonesian