Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The story behind Abdurrahman

| Source: The Jakarta Post

The story behind Abdurrahman

This is the second of two articles on a lesser known side of
President Abdurrahman Wahid by Indonesian expert R. William
Liddle, professor of political science at The Ohio State
University.

OHIO (JP): What is the connection between My Name is Asher Lev
and Abdurrahman Wahid, or Gus Dur? At the simplest level, his
appreciation for the world of Asher Lev reflects his empathic
ability to enter the consciousness of others, remarkable in his
case since there is little love for Jews among most Indonesian
Muslims.

He read in the novel the Hebrew greeting and response "Sholom
aleichim, aleichim sholom" and saw, he told me, the familiar
Arabic "Salam alaikum, alaikum salam," used by Indonesian Muslims
as a mark of their Islamic identity, differentiating them from
others. To Gus Dur, however, the similarity of the phrases
signified not only the common origins of the two religions but
more deeply the universality of the human religious experience.

His love for the novel also helps to explain his long
fascination with Jews and Israel, a country that he has visited
several times as a private citizen and with which he now proposes
as president to establish economic relations.

More deeply, however, the novel is a mirror to Gus Dur for two
reasons. First, the Hasidic yeshiva-centered world described by
Potok looks remarkably like the pesantren or Islamic boarding
school-centered world of traditional Indonesian Islam.

To be a student in these schools is to be a member of a moral
community possessing shared values and beliefs that differentiate
initiates from outsiders. It is an intense experience that
creates strong lifelong bonds among the students and between them
and their teachers. At the center of both is a respected, even
charismatic, leader, the Rebbe or the Kyai, who is to be obeyed
without question.

The yeshiva and the pesantren are also central institutions of
the communities they serve, Hasidic Jews and traditional
Indonesian Muslims. The Rebbe and the Kyai are consulted as a
matter of course when serious family or community problems arise,
and their advice is rarely rejected.

Second, as strong, even charismatic, leaders the Rebbe and the
Kyai have the principal responsibility for shaping their
communities' futures. In order to respond to the challenges of
their time and place, they must have a broader social and
cultural horizon than their members.

They must be bridges to other worlds, non-observant Jewish and
Gentile America in the case of the Hasidic yeshiva, modern
Indonesian and global society and culture in the case of the
Muslim pesantren. In this respect the Rebbe in My Name is Asher
Lev affirmed for Gus Dur his own conception of the ideal NU Kyai,
a leader who is firmly rooted in the tradition of classical Sunni
Islam and for that very reason is capable of flexibly
interpreting or even reshaping that tradition to meet the
challenges of the modern world.

It is the Rebbe, not Asher's equally pious but intellectually
and morally conventional father, who believes that it is possible
to be both an observant Jew and a great 20th century artist. By
giving him Jacob Kahn as a teacher (in itself a gesture natural
to the yeshiva tradition), the Rebbe makes Asher's success
outside the Jewish world possible.

For Gus Dur there is a very personal element in all this. In
some respects, he is both the Rebbe and Asher Lev. His
grandfather was the founder of Nahdlatul Ulama (NU), his father a
prominent NU leader, and it was expected that Gus Dur would
eventually step into their shoes. As a boy and young man,
however, he was a maverick with a sharp mind, uncomfortable with
conventional Islamic beliefs and practices and eager to expand
his horizons. After his study in Baghdad and Cairo (where he
earned no degrees) he spent time at several European universities
before returning home in the mid-1970s.

He then began his career as a Jakarta-based social activist,
which included writing over the next several years a series of
remarkable columns in Tempo magazine. Each of these columns told
a story about a wise Rebbe-like Kyai who solves a contemporary
social problem that conventional approaches, based on modern
technology or organization alone, could not overcome.

In these columns it is easy to see the Gus Dur who has always
had a chip on his shoulder, who disdains the modernist Muslims
too eager to discard Islamic and Indonesian history and culture
in favor of an unmediated application of the Koran to
contemporary life.

But his larger purpose was a positive one, and not restricted
to the Muslim community: to demonstrate that traditional roles,
values and practices like those of the Kyai are both necessary to
the transition to a modern society and an inescapable part of the
specifically Indonesian modernity that he hoped to build. He was
also implicitly offering himself, though for many years without
much hope of success, as a kind of Kyai-President, a blend of
traditional and modern roles.

The concept of a Kyai-President has its strengths and
weaknesses. Perhaps its greatest strength is its familiarity and
therefore instant legitimacy to tens of millions of Indonesians
from most regions and ethnic backgrounds.

This characteristic will certainly help the reformers, Gus Dur
among them, who are attempting to replace former President
Soeharto's army-backed authoritarian New Order with a more
democratic system.

Its most glaring weakness is its lack of rules and procedures
through which leaders can be held accountable to their
constituencies. The Kyai achieves his position through a
combination of birth, education, and a gradual acceptance of his
knowledge and teaching ability by other Kyai, potential students
and their parents, and the larger traditional Muslim community.
There is no regular procedure by which he is chosen or, perhaps
more importantly, by which he can be removed.

For the most part, therefore, the institutions which hold the
president accountable will have to be borrowed from other
traditions, notably that of the West and democratic East Asia.

This process was begun by President B.J. Habibie, the
successor to Soeharto, whose government quickly bowed to popular
pressure for a free press and democratic elections. It is
continuing under Gus Dur, the first democratically elected
president in Indonesian history.

The People's Consultative Assembly that elected him is now
preparing constitutional amendments and regulations that will
constrain future presidents and insure a greater role for the
House of Representative and an independent judiciary. The new
president has also responded quickly to regional demands to
create a de facto federal system, in which provinces will elect
their own legislatures and governors.

Despite its lack of a concept of institutional accountability,
traditional Islam may yet make a significant contribution to
Indonesian democratization through Gus Dur the Kyai-President.
Both the Rebbe in My Name is Asher Lev and the many Kyai whose
stories were written down by Gus Dur were distinguished for their
combination of deep roots and an open, flexible, and inclusive
approach to outsiders and to the future.

In the end, Asher Lev went too far, crossed a boundary where
the Rebbe could not go, leaving Asher with only his mythic
ancestor to accompany him. On his past record, there is a good
chance that Gus Dur will draw the boundaries in a way that will
keep the major players -- ethnic and regional as well as
religious -- inside the nation while moving steadily toward
democratization of the state.

More from 10 February 2000 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-story-behind-abdurrahman-1447893297-1289232)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print