Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Secret to Zohran Mamdani's Solid Voter Coalition, According to US Observers

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
The Secret to Zohran Mamdani's Solid Voter Coalition, According to US Observers
Image: Republika

Zohran Mamdani is becoming increasingly difficult to define through a single political label. He is known as a socialist politician who seeks to expand the government’s role in the economic lives of New Yorkers, yet simultaneously demonstrates an ability to work with United States President Donald Trump, who stands ideologically far apart from him.

There is another aspect drawing the attention of observers. Mamdani’s consistent stance regarding Israel is viewed not only as a matter of political conviction but also as something that intersects with the voter groups that propelled him to the New York Mayoralty.

Three opinion pieces published in US media in close succession reveal these three faces of Mamdani. The New York Post Editorial Board examines his economic policies; conservative columnist Marc A. Thiessen of The Washington Post highlights the pragmatism of his relationship with Trump; and Seth Pinsky in The Forward attempts to interpret the link between Israel issues and the strength of Mamdani’s political coalition.

While the three do not reach the same conclusion, reading them side-by-side provides a more complete picture of one of the most discussed politicians in the United States.

Expanding the Government

The sharpest criticism comes from the New York Post Editorial Board. In an editorial titled “Mamdani’s brilliant economic Rx: More government jobs,” published on Tuesday (29/09/2026), the media outlet uses the launch of the Jobs NYC Center as a gateway to question the direction of Mamdani’s economic policy.

The Jobs NYC Center is designed as a hub connecting New Yorkers with opportunities in the public service sector. Mamdani inaugurated the programme by administering the oaths of 17 city government employees recruited during the programme’s initial phase in August.

For the New York Post, the issue is not the 17 new employees themselves. The outlet views this as part of a larger question: as private sector job creation in New York slows down, is increasing government employment the correct answer?

New York’s unemployment rate in August was recorded at 4.8 per cent, while the national unemployment rate stood at 4.1 per cent. The New York Post also noted that over the past year, the city added only 27,600 private sector jobs within a workforce of approximately 4.2 million.

At the same time, the New York City government employs around 308,000 full-time staff. This figure does not include the workforce in agencies such as the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), NYC Health + Hospitals, and the City University of New York (CUNY).

If workers in those agencies are included, according to the New York Post, the number of people employed by various government agencies in New York approaches 570,000. There are also workers in various social service agencies funded by the city.

This is where the editorial’s primary criticism is directed at Mamdani. The New York Post argues that increasing the number of government jobs means increasing the burden that must ultimately be borne through taxation.

The outlet then brings this issue into the political realm. According to the New York Post editorial, the growth of the government workforce also has the potential to strengthen support for Mamdani’s agenda, which seeks a larger government role, including through public sector unions.

It is important to note that this final point represents the view of the New York Post editorial board, rather than an established fact. The choice of words in the editorial also reflects the media outlet’s critical stance towards socialism and Mamdani’s economic policies.

However, behind the sharp language, there is an economic question worth considering. If government jobs continue to increase while private sector job growth lags, how will the city government secure sufficient revenue to fund its programmes in the long term?

Making Peace with Trump

Four days before the New York Post editorial was published, Marc A. Thiessen presented a different portrait of Mamdani. The conservative columnist for The Washington Post finds something interesting in Mamdani’s relationship with Trump.

Thiessen is not a supporter of Mamdani’s politics. He was a speechwriter for President George W. Bush, a researcher at the conservative think tank American Enterprise Institute, and is well-known as a conservative columnist for The Washington Post.

In a piece titled “If Mamdani can play nice with Trump, why can’t Schumer and Jeffries?”, published on 24 September, Thiessen poses a simple question. If a socialist like Mamdani can speak and cooperate with Trump, why do Democratic leaders in Congress find it so difficult to do the same?

One of Thiessen’s sentences summarises this argument: “If Mamdani can have respectful, even friendly, meetings with Trump, why can’t Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries?” wrote Thiessen.

This question is striking because the relationship between Mamdani and Trump was previously far from harmonious. Both have previously exchanged harsh criticisms, and ideologically, it is almost impossible to place them in the same political camp.

However, since Mamdally became Mayor, the interests of governance have required them to communicate. They have even found areas where the federal government and the New York City government can work together.

One such area is the plan to build approximately 12,000 homes above active railway tracks in Queens. In this context, Mamdani has demonstrated that ideological differences do not always have to prevent cooperation when there are concrete interests for New York.

Thiessen sees this relationship as a broader political lesson. According to him, an individual can maintain…

More from 30 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-secret-to-zohran-mamdanis-solid-voter-coalition-according-to-us-observers-1790758786)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tm648x451/rahasia-zohran-mamdani-jaga-koalisi-pemilih-tetap-solid-menurut-pengamat-as), translated from Indonesian
Print