Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Scholar Who Stood Before a Tyrant and Criticised Power

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
The Scholar Who Stood Before a Tyrant and Criticised Power
Image: Republika

In the 8th century Hijri, it was no easy matter for a jurist living under a military government such as the Mamluk Sultanate to tell the rulers that the people’s wealth was not their own, that the ruler was merely a representative of the ummah and not a master over the people, and that the duty of a scholar was to stand in the way of a ruler when he committed injustice.

Yet Tajuddin Abdul Wahhab bin Ali as-Subki did all of that. He had to pay a heavy price for his stance, with dismissal from office, imprisonment and pursuit.

Even so, he left behind one of the most compelling intellectual legacies in the Islamic tradition on the critique of power and the ethics of governance.

In one of his masterpieces, Mui’d al-Ni’am wa Mubid as-Saqam, as-Subki highlighted what he regarded as the ‘crimes’ committed by some sultans of his own time and of earlier periods, particularly in the management and squandering of wealth.

He criticised the habit of giving vast amounts of wealth to poets and sycophants, while the majority of Muslims lived in poverty, deprivation and hardship.

He said, ‘History is filled with stories of people who gave thousands to poets, thousands to mamluks, and thousands for entertainment. All of that ultimately became a disaster for those who did it.’

As-Subki then compared such behaviour with the condition of the Baitul Mal during the time of Umar bin Khattab. He reminded his readers that Umar died wearing only a garment for which he had no other as a replacement.

Umar even once refused to give anything from the Baitul Mal to someone who recited poetry for him.

After that, as-Subki criticised the sultans of his own time in very open language, without any allusion.

‘This is the way of life of the people of truth and religion. We do not demand that the people of our time reach that station, because they will not be able to attain it. But we remind them of it, in the hope that they may return to the right path or at least reduce what they have been doing.’

More from 9 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-scholar-who-stood-before-a-tyrant-and-criticised-power-1786254700)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tjhl7j320/mestinya-beginilah-sosok-ulama-di-hadapan-pemimpin-zalim-dan-tamak-kekuasaan), translated from Indonesian
Print