Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Reason Why 'Tuyul' Do Not Steal Money from Banks Has Been Answered

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
The Reason Why 'Tuyul' Do Not Steal Money from Banks Has Been Answered
Image: CNBC Indonesia

The story of the ‘tuyul’ has long been embedded in Indonesian folklore. This supernatural creature is believed to have the ability to take money, which is then given to its master. This has led to the question: why do tuyuls not steal money from banks? Is it because they are unable to?

In ‘Dunia Hantu Orang Jawa’ (2004), cultural expert Suwardi Endraswara writes that tuyul activities are carried out from house to house, and their work is not limited to stealing money, but also valuable items and documents. Typically, this is performed by individuals obsessed with wealth. However, to date, there have been no recorded cases of banks losing money due to theft by these small, child-like supernatural beings.

Various theories circulate online to answer this question. Some suggest that tuyuls fear metal, which is why they avoid bank vaults, while others claim banks are protected by other supernatural entities that tuyuls fear. While these answers are merely speculative and illogical, there is a scientific explanation behind this mystical tale that explains why tuyuls do not target banks or electronic money balances.

To understand this, one must look back to 1870, when the Dutch implemented the ‘Open Door Policy’ or economic liberalisation, replacing the Cultivation System. While this change appeared to bring fresh air and potential prosperity, the reality was different. According to Jan Luiten van Zereden and Daan Marks in ‘Ekonomi Indonesia 1800-2010’ (2012), economic liberalisation birthed a new colonial regime involving the takeover of peasant plantations to be converted into large-scale plantations and sugar factories.

This situation plunged society into hardship, particularly small-scale farmers in Java, who fell deeper into poverty as they lost control over plantation lands. Conversely, a segment of society prospered under this system: traders, both indigenous and Chinese, who rapidly became ‘newly rich’. This sudden rise in wealth caused bewilderment among the increasingly impoverished farmers, who could not fathom the origins of such wealth.

At that time, farmers lived a subsistence lifestyle. According to Ong Hok Ham in ‘Wahyu yang Hilang Negeri Yang Guncang’ (2019), they farmed merely enough for their own consumption. Any surplus was used for tributes or sold. Consequently, they believed that the accumulation of wealth should be a transparent process involving visible effort. The problem was that they could not see the hard work behind the sudden wealth of the new merchant class.

Because these traders could not prove the origins of their wealth when questioned, resentment and jealousy grew among the farmers. Furthermore, as noted by George Quinn in ‘An Excursion to Java’s Get Rich Quick Tree’ (2009), farmers believed that wealth must be accountable. When the newly wealthy failed to account for their riches, farmers accused them of theft.

Deeply rooted in mystical views, farmers perceived such theft as the result of cooperation between the wealthy and supernatural beings, such as the tuyul. The tuyul is a long-standing Javanese mythological figure—a small, bald, supernatural entity that can be ‘kept’ to bring wealth. Thus, envious farmers accused the new wealthy class of using unholy methods. This accusation, as Ong Hok Ham writes in ‘Dari Soal Priayi sampai Nyi Blorong’ (2002), caused successful traders and entrepreneurs to lose social status, as they were deemed ‘vile’ for accumulating wealth through demonic alliances.

In reality, this phenomenon was a byproduct of Dutch colonial policies that allowed certain entrepreneurs to reap sudden benefits. This resentment did not just affect personal relationships; it changed how the wealthy conducted transactions. The wealthy began to purchase items that did not overtly display their riches, such as gold or luxury goods. If they purchased land or houses, they risked being accused by farmers of keeping ‘tuyuls’. These baseless accusations contributed to the enduring popularity of the tuyul myth in Indonesia, sustained by an agrarian society’s long-standing imagination and suspicion.

More from 19 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-reason-why-tuyul-do-not-steal-money-from-banks-has-been-answered-1789797080)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20260919105557-17-769192/terjawab-sudah-alasan-tuyul-ogah-curi-uang-di-bank), translated from Indonesian
Print