The Reason Tuyul Won’t Steal Money from Banks, Explained
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – Many Indonesians are familiar with the tuyul, a supernatural figure said to steal money from house to house. Yet people often ask why this supposed ability cannot be used to rob banks.
Cultural observer Suwardi Endraswara wrote in Dunia Hantu Orang Jawa (2004) that tuyul go from house to house, and their work is not limited to stealing money: they are also said to take goods and valuable documents. They are usually employed by someone obsessed with wealth.
To date, however, there have been no cases of a bank losing money to theft by these small, childlike supernatural beings.
Online, various explanations for this question can be found. Some say tuyul fear metal because money in banks is kept in vaults. Others claim that banks have supernatural “guardians” feared by tuyul.
Such answers are merely speculation about something that is itself illogical. Whatever the answer, however, there is a scientific explanation behind the tuyul legend—one that challenges the being’s existence and may also explain why tuyul are not said to steal money from banks or take someone’s e-money balance.
To understand the explanation, we need to go back to 1870. That year, the Dutch introduced the open-door policy, or economic liberalisation, replacing the Cultivation System. At first glance, the change seemed promising, as it was thought capable of improving people’s welfare. In reality, it did not.
According to Jan Luiten van Zanden and Daan Marks in Ekonomi Indonesia 1800–2010 (2012), economic liberalisation instead created a new colonial regime in which smallholders’ plantations were taken over and converted into large estates and sugar factories.
This situation worsened people’s lives, particularly those of small-scale farmers in Java, who sank further into poverty because they no longer controlled their land.
At the same time, some people prospered under the system. Traders, both indigenous and Chinese, became newly wealthy in a short period. Their rapid rise in fortunes puzzled increasingly impoverished farmers, who wondered where the wealth had come from.
It is worth noting that farmers at the time lived simply. According to Ong Hok Ham in Wahyu yang Hilang Negeri Yang Guncang (2019), they followed a subsistence system: they farmed only enough for their own consumption. Any surplus produce was either given as tribute or sold.
As a result, they viewed the accumulation of wealth as something that should happen openly. In other words, everyone was expected to go through a clear process and make visible efforts that others could witness.
The problem was that farmers could not see the new rich working hard. Nor could they verify the origins of their wealth when asked. This fuelled envy and resentment towards traders who had acquired such substantial fortunes.
Moreover, according to George Quinn in An Excursion to Java’s Get Rich Quick Tree (2009), farmers believed that the arrival of wealth had to be accounted for. When the wealthy could not explain where their money came from, farmers grew envious and accused them of theft.
Because their worldview was steeped in mysticism, farmers believed the theft was carried out through the wealthy’s collaboration with invisible supernatural beings. One such being was the tuyul, a long-established figure in Javanese mythology: a small, bald spirit or ghost that could be kept as a familiar.
Farmers who were envious of sudden wealth therefore accused the newly rich of acquiring it through illicit means. Ong Hok Ham writes in another book, Dari Soal Priayi sampai Nyi Blorong (2002), that these accusations caused successful traders and businesspeople to lose social standing.
They were regarded as “base” because they were thought to have amassed wealth illicitly by consorting with the devil. In reality, their fortunes were the result of changes in Dutch colonial policy that had brought them unexpected gains.
Farmers’ dislike of those who became rich suddenly affected more than personal relationships; it also changed how wealthy people spent their money.
The wealthy consequently tended to buy goods that did not reveal the full extent of their riches, such as gold or luxury items. If they bought land or a house, farmers might accuse them of keeping a devil or tuyul.
These baseless accusations helped make the tuyul increasingly popular as a supernatural figure associated with wealth, and the legend has remained popular in Indonesia to this day. The country’s long-standing agrarian way of life further entrenched the popular imagination and accusations surrounding the use of tuyul.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-reason-tuyul-wont-steal-money-from-banks-explained-1792237822)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261017151953-17-777101/terjawab-sudah-alasan-tuyul-ogah-curi-uang-di-bank), translated from Indonesian