The Real Reason Westerners Use Toilet Paper Instead of Water
The world seems divided into two camps when it comes to toilet hygiene: those who wash with water and those who use toilet paper. Typically, the majority who use water come from the East, while paper users are from the West. Why has this come to be?
The habit of cleaning oneself after defecation has existed for a long time, with each region having different cultural practices that certainly did not involve tissue paper. People would clean themselves according to local customs and climatic conditions, using water, leaves, grass, stones, or just their hands. In 6th-century BC Rome, for instance, residents used stones. In the Middle East, water was used for cleansing in accordance with religious teachings.
According to the 2012 study ‘Toilet hygiene in the classical era’, the use of paper as a cleaning tool was first detected in China, not the Western world. The Chinese had created paper as a further development of their earlier invention, and the first trace of toilet paper in the West appeared in the 16th century. French writer Francois Rabelais was the first to mention toilet paper, though he noted it was not effective for cleaning.
So, if it was deemed ineffective, why did Westerners or those in non-tropical climates continue using it? According to Buzz Feed, the reason is the weather. Cold weather naturally makes people reluctant to come into contact with water, whether for bathing or cleaning. Conversely, those in tropical societies do not mind contact with water; in fact, they feel overheated without it. This is the basis for the difference in cleaning media between the two societies. Westerners, or generally those in cold climates, use tissue, while the rest use water. The use of water for cleansing also aligns with religious teachings in both Islam and Hinduism.
As reported by CNN International, the popularity of toilet paper in non-tropical societies coincided with the massive emergence of tissue factories, especially after the innovation of the toilet roll in 1890. Beyond climate, another influencing factor is diet. Westerners who typically consume low-fibre foods produce less waste with lower water content, so they clean using only tissue. In contrast, people in Asia, Africa, and parts of Europe often eat high-fibre foods that produce more waste and water, making water the best method for cleaning.
Regardless of the divide between water and tissue users, scientific research has proven that washing with water is cleaner, as bacteria and germs can be completely removed. Nevertheless, the use of toilet paper is difficult to abandon because it is deeply tied to culture and ingrained across generations. That is the reason why Westerners, or generally people in cold climates, are accustomed to cleaning only with tissue.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-real-reason-westerners-use-toilet-paper-instead-of-water-1783734641)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20260710225453-33-749993/alasan-sebenarnya-orang-barat-cebok-pakai-tisu-kenapa-bukan-air), translated from Indonesian