Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The President’s Phone-Tapping and Allegations of Treason

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
The President’s Phone-Tapping and Allegations of Treason
Image: CNBC Indonesia

In the first week of November 2026, Indonesians were startled by reports of alleged surveillance targeting Prabowo Subianto, the President of the Republic of Indonesia. The story spread across television, online media and social media.

On 4 November 2026, CNN Indonesia published an article entitled “How the Alleged Tapping of Prabowo by Listyo Sigit and Others Came to Light”. Citing information from the Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim) of the National Police, the report said the alleged illegal surveillance of Prabowo, reportedly involving General Listyo Sigit Prabowo and several others, came to light after a complaint was filed. Listyo and two serving police generals have been named as suspects in the case.

National Police Criminal Investigation Agency chief Commissioner General Asep Safrudin said the alleged surveillance took place between 2025 and 2026, while Listyo was still serving as National Police chief. At a press conference at Bareskrim on Tuesday, 3 November 2026, Asep said the suspects allegedly ordered surveillance without following the procedures set out in National Police Regulation No. 5 of 2010. Several telephone numbers were allegedly entered into the Lawful Interception Management System (LIMS) server without verification.

Meanwhile, on 4 November 2026, Kompas.com published an article entitled “Not for the State: Listyo’s Alleged Tapping of Prabowo Suspected of Having a Political Motive”. It quoted National Police Commission (Kompolnas) commissioner Adrianus Meliala, who suspected the surveillance was carried out neither in the interests of the state nor of the police institution, but for the benefit of another party. His remarks merit consideration because they raise the possibility of a motive beyond law enforcement or the police’s institutional interests.

The issue became more serious when the alleged surveillance was linked to the possibility of treason. On 4 November 2026, CNBC Indonesia, in an article entitled “Palace Says Listyo and Others’ Tapping Case Points to Treason”, quoted State Secretary Prasetyo Hadi.

He said the Palace viewed the alleged surveillance of Prabowo and several other officials by three senior police officers as conduct pointing towards treason. The act was considered potentially capable of endangering the safety of the country’s leaders and the national interest. The Palace’s statement raises a fundamental legal question: can the surveillance of Prabowo in itself be classified as treason?

Treason and the commencement of execution

Indonesia’s National Criminal Code regulates treason in Part Two, specifically Paragraph 1 on treason against the President and/or Vice-President. Article 191 states:

“Any Person who commits treason with the intention of killing or depriving the President and/or Vice-President of their liberty, or rendering the President and/or Vice-President unable to govern, shall be punished by death, life imprisonment or imprisonment for a maximum of 20 (twenty) years.”

Under this wording, treason against the President and/or Vice-President requires one of three objectives: the intention to kill, deprive of liberty, or render the President and/or Vice-President unable to govern.

Article 160 of the National Criminal Code further defines treason as an intention to carry out an attack that has been realised through preparatory acts. Treason therefore cannot be established merely by the existence of someone’s intention or thoughts. That intention must be manifested in conduct that meets the definition set out in the law.

In the context of the alleged surveillance of the President, the legal question is whether the surveillance was part of preparations for an attack with one of the intentions specified in Article 191.

If the surveillance was intended only to obtain information illegally, without any connection to an objective of attacking the President or paralysing the government, it cannot automatically be classified as treason.

It is therefore premature to state outright that the alleged surveillance points towards treason. At the time of the reports, the motives, aims and interests behind the surveillance had not yet been fully revealed. The claim that the conduct may amount to treason remains an allegation that must be tested through investigation and the presentation of evidence.

Conspiracy and preparation to commit treason

That said, the possibility that the conduct went beyond illegal surveillance cannot be ruled out. If several people were involved, investigators need to establish whether they reached an agreement to pursue a particular unlawful objective.

Article 13 of the National Criminal Code governs criminal conspiracy. It provides that a conspiracy exists when two or more people agree to commit an offence. However, conspiracy is punishable only where the law expressly provides for it.

In other words, the involvement of several people in a criminal act does not, by itself, constitute a criminal conspiracy. It must be proved that they agreed to commit a specific offence and that legislation criminalises the conspiracy in question.

In relation to treason, Article 196 of the National Criminal Code also requires consideration. It specifically provides for punishment for conspiracy or preparation to commit the offences set out in Articles 191 to 194. This matters because criminal law covers not only completed acts of treason, but also conspiracies or preparations intended to bring about those offences.

Accordingly, if the surveillance of the President proves to have been part of an agreement or a series of preparations to commit treason, Article 196 may be relevant. However, an agreement to carry out illegal surveillance must be clearly distinguished from an agreement to commit treason. The two offences have different objects and purposes.

The crucial task is to determine thoroughly whether the surveillance was a standalone offence or part of a sequence of acts pursuing a more far-reaching objective.

Political motives in crimes against state power

The motive for the surveillance should be treated as an important factor in establishing the nature and purpose of the conduct. Several possibilities warrant investigation, although for now they remain hypotheses.

First, the surveillance may have been intended to obtain strategic information about the President’s policies and decisions. Second, it may have been designed to build leverage or political influence over the President and those around him.

Third, it may have formed part of an effort to control, weaken or disrupt the running of the government. Fourth, and more seriously, the surveillance may have been an initial step in a plan to obstruct the President from carrying out his constitutional functions, or even to pave the way for a seizure of power.

None of these possibilities should be treated as fact without supporting evidence. However, to understand the nature of crimes involving political power, it is useful to consider Stephen Schafer’s arguments in his book The Political Criminal: The Problem of Morality and Crime (1974).

Schafer offers a perspective in which political crime cannot be separated from the relationship between crime, power, political objectives and morality. From this perspective, it is important to consider whether an act is committed solely for personal gain or forms part of an effort to attain, maintain or influence political power.

Applied to the alleged surveillance of the President, the issue is not merely whether surveillance procedures were breached, but also whether a broader political objective lay behind the conduct.

If the surveillance was intended to obtain information that would then be used as a tool of political pressure, the nature of the conduct requires further analysis—particularly if evidence emerges of a series of actions aimed at weakening or paralysing the legitimate government’s authority.

It must nevertheless be stressed that a politically motivated crime is not necessarily treason. Political motive may help explain the background to an act, but the classification of treason must still depend on whether the elements of the offence set out in the National Criminal Code have been met.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the alleged surveillance of the President should not be viewed merely as a technical breach of surveillance procedures. If it was indeed carried out by people with authority and access to state surveillance equipment—and especially if that authority was abused for interests outside those of the state—the case touches on more fundamental issues: abuse of power and threats to the functioning of government.

However, care is still needed when assigning a legal classification. An act whose elements have not been proved should not be labelled treason in advance. Conversely, the possibility of a more serious crime behind the surveillance should not be ignored.

The investigation must therefore establish not only who ordered and carried out the surveillance, but also who stood to benefit, why the information was obtained, to whom it was passed, and whether there was an agreement or preparation to carry out acts that could be classified as treason.

In cases involving state power, the questions are not only who committed the offence and how it was carried out, but also why it was committed and whose interests it was intended to serve.

More from 5 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-presidents-phone-tapping-and-allegations-of-treason-1793857854)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261105112658-14-782558/penyadapan-presiden-dan-dugaan-makar), translated from Indonesian
Print