Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Practical Reasoning of Indonesian Muslims in a MacIntyrean Perspective

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
The Practical Reasoning of Indonesian Muslims in a MacIntyrean Perspective
Image: Media Indonesia

In this fast-paced digital and globalised era, we often find ourselves at confusing moral crossroads. On one hand, the current of modernity offers all manner of individual freedoms and materialistic pleasures. On the other, there remains a hope for the realisation of social justice and idealistic virtues imbued with noble values. This paradox of modernity was radically dissected by the prominent Scottish-born philosopher, Alasdair MacIntyre (1929-2025), in his various works, from his magnum opus, ‘After Virtue’ (1981), to ‘Ethics in the Conflicts of Modernity: An Essay on Desire, Practical Reasoning, and Narrative’, published exactly a decade ago (2016).

Although his work was born to highlight problems in the West, many critical nuances can be drawn from it, especially for reading the dynamics of the Muslim community in Indonesia today, which is at the epicentre of modernity’s storm. Our society still appears hesitant in addressing how to balance religious piety, social fragmentation, the demands of the free-market economy, and the pull of identity politics.

To understand MacIntyre’s grand narrative, we must see how he diagnoses the failure of modern morality. MacIntyre argues that liberalism and late-modern capitalism are not merely political and economic systems but a distortive moral order that aggressively shapes desires, cripples practical reasoning, and tears apart the life narratives of modern humans.

Firstly, MacIntyre attacks what he calls emotivism and expressivism, the view that all moral judgements are nothing more than expressions of emotion or subjective preference. In the culture of late-modern capitalism, humans are systematically conditioned by the market, advertising, and social media algorithms to become consumers who maximise personal preferences. We are dictated to constantly desire more commodities. The latent danger of this system is that it blurs the crucial distinction between what we want and what we need.

Secondly, through a neo-Aristotelian lens, MacIntyre reaffirms the concept of humans as dependent rational animals. Individual moral development can only be achieved through active participation in local communities (family, school, workplace) that are oriented towards the common good. The common good is not the accumulation of individual selfish goods, but a social condition where community members can help each other achieve self-actualisation. Capitalism, for MacIntyre, is the primary enemy of this common good because it institutionalises greed and views human relationships merely as contractual transactions for mutual exploitation.

Thirdly, modernity has caused the fragmentation of life narratives. For MacIntyre, a person can only act ethically if their life has a narrative unity from birth to death. Modernity, however, demolishes this structure. Modern humans are forced to wear different, isolated masks: at the office, they must be ruthless for efficiency; in the market, a selfish consumer; at home, a loving parent; and in the place of worship, a pious servant. When life is fragmented, practical reasoning is paralysed, and the individual becomes vulnerable to losing their moral compass.

When we bring MacIntyre’s lens to Indonesia, we can clearly see the ripples of moral conflict experienced by modern Muslim society. Interestingly, the Islamic tradition in the archipelago, like elsewhere, also possesses unique and rich ethical sources and institutions. The question is, what is the fate of this tradition when it confronts modernity?

One of the most striking dynamics in Indonesia over the past decade is the ‘hijrah’ movement, especially among the urban Muslim middle class. On the surface, this shows a religious passion that should be appreciated. However, using MacIntyre’s analysis of the dictation of desire by capitalism, we find another, highly problematic side: how late-modern capitalism has tamed and commodified religious movements. The desire to be a pious Muslim is quickly captured by the market as a highly profitable new niche. A halal lifestyle economy was born, from tourism, exclusive housing, and sharia-labelled cosmetics and fashion, to grand hijrah festivals filled with shopping booths.

This is where the ethical reasoning of the Muslim community is truly tested. Is their behavioural change based on an objective search for moral virtue, or has their religious desire been co-opted by the market into mere new aesthetic-expressive satisfaction? When piety is measured by what is bought, not how character is formed, religion has submitted to the logic of the market.

Muslim communities, especially in big cities, also experience exhausting role fragmentation. During the day, in a competitive corporate ecosystem, they are required to adopt a utilitarian ethos to pursue targets and compete aggressively. Yet, at night and on weekends, they are confronted with sermons about the virtues of zuhud (asceticism) and qana’ah (contentment). The inability to reconcile these two opposing worlds ultimately creates another problem. To cope, many seek shortcuts by consuming puritanical trends and instant religious content. Unfortunately, these often kill deep practical reasoning and trigger momentary emotions. As a result, the religion they receive is often reduced to black-and-white legalism.

More from 5 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-practical-reasoning-of-indonesian-muslims-in-a-macintyrean-perspective-1785883857)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/opini/918373/nalar-praktis-muslim-indonesia-dalam-perspektif-macintyrean), translated from Indonesian
Print