Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Paradox of Islamic Financial Inclusion: Literacy Does Not Equal Participation

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
The Paradox of Islamic Financial Inclusion: Literacy Does Not Equal Participation
Image: CNBC Indonesia

There is good news from the 2026 National Survey of Financial Literacy and Inclusion (SNLIK), but at the same time a paradox worth reflecting on. National financial literacy increased from 66.64 percent in 2025 to 69.57 percent in 2026. Financial inclusion also rose from 92.74 percent to 93.61 percent. Indonesia is getting closer to a condition where almost the entire population is in touch with formal financial services.

However, a different story emerges in Islamic finance. Islamic financial literacy actually fell slightly from 43.42 percent to 43.07 percent, while inclusion declined from 13.41 percent to 13.24 percent. The figures may move only slightly, but the message is significant: when the national financial ecosystem becomes more inclusive, Islamic finance has not fully enjoyed that momentum.

This finding is even more important because SNLIK 2026 has a much broader statistical base. The collaborative survey by OJK, BPS, and LPS covers 75,000 household samples across 38 provinces and 514 regencies/cities, a significant increase from 10,800 samples in the previous SNLIK.

Literacy is not merely measuring whether someone has heard of a financial product, but rather knowledge, skills, confidence, attitudes, and behaviour. This is where a more fundamental question arises: why has knowledge about Islamic finance not yet turned into participation?

From Literacy Gap to Conversion Gap

So far, the low penetration of Islamic finance has often been explained as a matter of literacy. The assumption is simple: people have not used Islamic products because they do not yet understand them. The answer, therefore, is socialisation, education, seminars, campaigns, and increased knowledge.

SNLIK 2026 invites us to re-examine that assumption. Islamic literacy has reached 43.07 percent, but inclusion is only 13.24 percent. There is a gap of 29.83 percentage points between people classified as literate and those who use Islamic products or services. Simply put, knowledge has not automatically translated into usage. This can be called the Islamic finance conversion gap.

From a behavioural economics perspective, people do not always make decisions based on their knowledge and normative preferences. A person can understand the benefits of saving but still not save; understand the importance of insurance but not buy a policy; even have a preference for halal products but still choose non-Islamic financial services because they are easier, cheaper, more familiar, or available in the apps they use every day.

This phenomenon is close to the intention-behaviour gap: the distance between what a person knows or intends and their actual actions. Recent research in Malaysia using the Theory of Planned Behaviour even found that social-cognitive factors strongly explain the intention and adoption behaviour of Islamic banking; perceived behavioural control is an important predictor of intention, while intention itself has a strong influence on behaviour.

Literacy remains important, but knowledge alone is not enough. Therefore, the challenge for Indonesian Islamic finance appears to be shifting from merely an awareness problem to a conversion problem.

Learning from Malaysia, Pakistan, and the UAE

International comparisons clarify the issue. Malaysia has not only built its Islamic finance industry through education but has embedded it into the main architecture of the financial system. As of July 2025, its Islamic banking assets reached RM1.58 trillion, or 38.7 percent of total banking assets. More interestingly, Islamic financing has controlled 47.5 percent of the total loans and financing in Malaysia’s banking system.

This means that Islamic products in Malaysia are increasingly not treated as alternative products solely for Muslim consumers. They have become part of the mainstream financial choice. Network integration is also important. As an illustration, CIMB Islamic leverages the operational integration and network of its parent group; by the end of 2025, Islamic financing had contributed 32.1 percent of CIMB Group’s total financing.

Pakistan offers another comparison. By the end of 2025, Islamic banking institutions had controlled around 23 percent of assets and 27.8 percent of deposits in the banking system. Their network grew by 1,545 offices in just one year to reach 7,562 branches.

In the UAE, Islamic bank assets in April 2026 were around AED989 billion, or about 18 percent of banking system assets. The government has even placed the expansion of digital services as one of the elements of its Islamic finance industry development strategy.

Türkiye shows that a large Muslim population does not automatically produce high penetration. Participation banking has grown rapidly and its assets reached around TRY4.3 trillion by the end of 2025, but the 15 percent share target previously set for 2025 has not been achieved. This experience reminds us that demography is potential demand, not effective demand.

These comparisons are certainly not entirely apple-to-apple: SNLIK measures usage at the individual level, while the comparison figures above mainly describe the share of the banking industry. Yet both show the same problem from two sides: how far public preference has been successfully converted into the economic scale of the industry.

Inclusion Is Not Just Opening an Account

The World Bank distinguishes access from usage. In a broader conception, financial inclusion concerns access to and use of appropriate and affordable services, while quality, financial capability, and consumer protection determine whether that access is truly beneficial.

Global Findex 2025 further confirms this transformation. As many as 79 percent of adults worldwide now have a financial account, up from 74 percent in 2021. Digitalisation is one of the main drivers. The implication for Islamic finance is quite radical. We need to move from financial literacy to financial experience.

Consumers do not choose accounts, financing, investments, or protection merely because they understand the contract. They also consider price, transaction speed, app convenience, service location, payment interoperability, service quality, financing flexibility, and the benefits received.

In behavioural economics, friction matters. A few extra steps in opening an account, a less intuitive app, limited merchant options, or a longer financing process can change consumer decisions even when their initial preference is Islamic. Therefore, the main competitor of Islamic banks is not only conventional banks. Their competitor is friction.

Building a Conversion Architecture

The next agenda therefore cannot stop at increasing the literacy rate. Indonesia needs a conversion architecture: an ecosystem that shortens the journey from knowing, intending, trying, to ultimately using and staying. At least four shifts are needed in a conversion architecture.

First, from product-centric to customer-centric Islamic finance. A product is not enough merely to be sharia-compliant; it must be economically competitive and superior in experience. Sharia compliance is a necessary condition, but convenience, price, speed, and relevance determine adoption.

Second, from campaign-based literacy to embedded literacy. The best education does not always take place in a seminar room. Literacy can be instilled when consumers open an account, choose an investment, pay with QR, apply for home financing, buy protection, or fulfil zakat and waqf. Knowledge arrives precisely when the decision is made.

Third, from institutional distribution to ecosystem distribution. Islamic finance must be present in the chain of people’s economic life: the halal ecosystem, pesantren, MSMEs, hajj and umrah, housing, health, education, digital trade, halal supply chains, and the creative industry. Islamic products should become an easy-to-find default option, not an alternative that must be sought.

Fourth, measures of success need to evolve from literacy and inclusion rates to active usage and impact. How many accounts are truly active? What proportion of digital transactions are Islamic? How many MSMEs have moved up a class after obtaining financing? How many families have become more resilient to shocks because they have Islamic savings, investments, and protection?

This direction is in line with OJK’s move in July 2026 to set three focuses for developing Islamic financial literacy and inclusion, including data-based strategies, digitalisation, and community needs.

From Preference to Participation

SNLIK 2026 ultimately delivers a deeper message than just two slightly declining figures. It shows that the problem of Indonesian Islamic finance may no longer be merely a lack of market potential, nor even merely a lack of knowledge. What has not yet fully formed is the bridge that turns knowledge and preference into economic behaviour.

Indonesia does not lack social capital to build Islamic finance. The halal ecosystem is growing, Islamic institutions are increasingly complete, digitalisation is expanding, and the public’s financing needs are enormous. But demographic potential does not automatically become market share. Identity does not automatically become transaction. Literacy does not automatically become inclusion.

Therefore, the next chapter cannot simply ask how many people understand Islamic finance. The more strategic question is: what makes them ultimately choose, use, and continue using Islamic finance?

When that question can be answered, Indonesian Islamic finance will move from literacy to participation, from potential demand to effective demand, and finally from merely enlarging market share to creating real economic and social impact.

For the future of Islamic finance is determined not only by how many people know it, but by how easily Islamic values are present as the best financial choice in everyday life.

More from 11 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-paradox-of-islamic-financial-inclusion-literacy-does-not-equal-participation-1786438325)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260811142213-14-758291/paradoks-inklusi-keuangan-syariah-literasi-belum-jadi-partisipasi), translated from Indonesian
Print