The Next Chapter: Gibran Supporter's Expert Witness Expelled from Constitutional Court Hearing
The hearing for the dispute over the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election results (PHPU), specifically concerning the educational requirements for Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy, has intensified. An expert witness representing Gibran’s supporters was expelled by the Constitutional Court (MK) judges, leading to a subsequent report to the Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK).
The incident began when the Constitutional Court judges expelled M. Rullyandi, a constitutional law expert from Jayabaya University, who was presented by the ‘Militan Gibran O8 Nusantara’ volunteer group, during a session held on Thursday night (1/10).
Constitutional Court Judge Arsul Sani stated that he had observed Rullyandi’s statements in a television talk show, where the expert claimed that the ongoing court proceedings regarding Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements were illegal, and further claimed the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court was illegal.
“I need clarification first regarding the expert, Mr Muhammad Rullyandi. I happened to watch your talk show, which also featured Mr Refly Harun, on a television station, where you stated that this trial is illegal and that the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court is illegal,” said Arsul.
Arsul requested an explanation from Rullyandi, questioning his willingness to serve as an expert in a proceeding that he himself had labelled as illegal.
“I request your explanation. If this trial is illegal, why are you acting as an expert in this case? Since the proceedings are illegal according to you,” Arsul remarked.
Arsul stated that the Court needed to ensure Rullyandi’s consistency and credibility as an expert. He also questioned whether the relevant parties were aware of Rullyandi’s statements regarding the trial.
“Unless in your testimony, you only intend to say that ‘this trial is illegal’. That would be fine, but you must explain it first. Including when you say that the current Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court is illegal. I have read your expert testimony and you did not mention the illegality of this trial; you spoke about Gustav Radbruch and so on. Please, let this be clarified through the presiding judge,” Ardo said.
Constitutional Court Deputy Chairman Saldi Isra, presiding over the hearing, subsequently demanded that Rullyandi first retract his statement calling the PHPU trial illegal. Saldi emphasised that Rullyandi could not present his expert opinion unless he retracted the statement.
“Before answering, you must retract that statement. Otherwise, you cannot utilise your expertise here. Because you cannot appear in a trial that you accuse of being illegal,” Saldi stated.
“May I respond, Your Honour?” Rullyandi asked.
“Proceed,” Saldi replied.
Rullyandi claimed he had never insulted the Constitutional Court, asserting that he was merely offering criticism to ensure the Court aligns with the 1945 Constitution.
“My criticism of the MK is to ensure it aligns with the meaning of the 1945 Constitution regarding the illegal trial, firstly. Secondly, regarding the illegal Chief Justice. This relates to a PTUN (Administrative Court) decision in which I served as an expert, the verdict of which annulled Decree Number 17 of 2023, as it was the result of a plenary meeting minutes for the election of the Chief Justice, Mr Suhartoyo, which was not followed up after becoming legally binding on 16 December 2024. Therefore, it should return to the constitution, where the Chief Justice is chosen from and by the Constitutional Court judges. However, Decree Number 8 still uses minutes that were annulled by the PTUN. Therefore, as someone who understands the law—having completed my Bachelor’s, Master’s, and Doctoral degrees—I am saying this Chief Justice is illegal. This is my legal view as a form of criticism, and I submitted my letter openly regarding the illegal Chief Justice in 2025, before these illegal proceedings took place,” he explained.
Saldi interrupted Rullyandi, stating that the panel of judges had concluded that if Rullyandi did not retract his ‘illegal trial’ statement made during the talk show, he could not participate.
“Enough. We have discussed that if you do not withdraw that, you cannot participate in this trial,” Saldi said.
Rullyandi stated that he would only retract the statement within the courtroom, noting that he felt pressured to do so.
“I retract. In this courtroom, only in this courtroom. My statement regarding the illegal trial was made because I was under pressure. For the sake of the nation and the state, I wish to present my legal views on this trial. I respect what the Panel of Judges has requested. Thank you,” Rullyandi said.
The judges then suspended the hearing to deliberate. Ultimately, Saldi announced that the panel agreed to accept Rullyandi’s testimony only in written form and requested him to leave the courtroom.
“We have decided that the testimony of Muhammad Rullyandi will be accepted in written form only, and no oral testimony will be provided. Thank you, and you are not permitted to say anything further. The second expert may proceed,” Saldi explained.
“You cannot, you cannot do any more, that is enough,” Saldi added.
“Very well, if that is the case, I respect the decision of Your Honour,” Rullyandi replied.
Following the hearing, M. Rullyandi reported Deputy Chairman Saldi Isra and Judge Arsul Sani to the Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK). Rullyandi alleges there are suspected violations of the code of ethics and judicial conduct by Saldi Isra.
“I assess that the actions of the reported judge, which I have reported today, specifically Professor Saldi Isra as the Deputy Chairman of the MK, were received by the MKMK secretariat at 14:50 WIB. I am reporting a violation of the code of ethics and judicial conduct by Deputy Chairman Professor Saldi Isra, regarding actions that contradict the principles of judicial power, namely that all parties must be heard…”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-next-chapter-gibran-supporters-expert-witness-expelled-from-constitutional-court-hearing-1791165368)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8692414/babak-selanjutnya-dari-pengusiran-ahli-relawan-gibran-di-sidang-mk), translated from Indonesian