The Kedungombo decision
The Kedungombo decision
Last week's decision of the Supreme Court in favor of farmers
at the Kedungombo reservoir site in Central Java must have come
as quite a blow to the state. Judging by the intensity of the
reactions expressed the other day by the governor and the
military commander of Central Java, one can feel more than just
anger and disappointment behind their words.
As reported by the press, the Supreme Court has ruled that the
government must pay Rp 50,000 for each square meter of land
formerly owned by 34 farmers, which was used for the Kedungombo
dam, plus Rp 2 billion for non-material losses incurred.
The farmers were among the thousands of families who lived on
a 6,700-hectare plot of land which they had to abandon when the
government started the Kedungombo reservoir project, financed by
the World Bank, in 1990.
Although they were removed from their villages, and their
land and houses were flooded, several hundreds of recalcitrant
families continued to resist. Some of them filed separate
lawsuits against the government. The legal battle has taken years
to settle. It was only last week that it became publicly known
that the Supreme Court had ruled that the government must pay the
huge amounts in compensation to the 34 farmers.
The decision has been hailed by many lawyers and non-
governmental organizations. On the other hand, many government
officials have expressed disbelief and consternation over the
verdict. Central Java Governor Soewardi reportedly plans to ask
the Supreme Court to review the decision, while Central Java
military commander Maj. Gen. Soeyono even went as far as to
question the authenticity of the decision.
It is indeed curious that it took almost a year for the
Supreme Court's decision, which was made on July 28, 1993, to
become known to the public. Some bureaucratic red tape was
reportedly to blame for the delay. But the question of the
originality of the decision has been settled because it has been
confirmed by the Supreme Court.
In any legal case, there must be one side which wins and
another which loses. Therefore, one can understand that the
Central Java authorities are upset by the Supreme Court's
decision. And one can assume that more Kedungombo farmers are
likely to sue the government in the coming days, following the
success of their counterparts.
And thus it is understandable that the government is said to
be planning to file a request for a review of the decision. And
yesterday it was reported that the Attorney General has, indeed,
decided to ask for a second look. We believe the request for a
new trial is reasonable and proper because it is well within the
boundaries of the legal procedures set out under our nation's
law.
Our concern is that some officials may somehow regard the
Supreme Court's decision as a blow to their personal self-esteem
and thus feel that they have lost face. And there seems to be
sufficient grounds for such concern. Last May, for instance, when
some lawyers in Yogyakarta and Semarang tried to raise the issue
again, several government officials bluntly declared that the
Kedungombo case was settled and closed, period.
We are concerned that some people might regard the Supreme
Court's decision as a slap in the face which must be defied. The
officials of any government, and that government itself, are, of
course, not above the law. Any feeling or belief that those in
authority can do no wrong is as obsolete as a fossil and
certainly not applicable in a state where law rules.
Hence, instead of regarding the Supreme Court's decision as an
offense, or even as a personal affront, we must all retain the
strength of common sense, keep ourselves calm and, above all,
respect our law.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-kedungombo-decision-1447893297-1023862)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post