Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Judicial Commission as a Means of Perfecting Judicial Power

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
The Judicial Commission as a Means of Perfecting Judicial Power
Image: detikcom

As a state governed by the rule of law, Indonesia emphasises the need to guarantee an independent judiciary, free from the influence of other branches of power, so that courts can uphold the law and deliver justice. The exercise of judicial power must bring benefit rather than harm.

Judicial independence refers to the broader realisation of the constitutional law’s purpose: “fair legal certainty” for the public. Conversely, the judicial function is diminished when the law operates amid uncertainty and injustice. Such conditions would be disastrous for the judiciary.

Achieving this constitutional purpose requires an independent judiciary. Securing judicial independence, in turn, requires oversight of judges. If oversight weakens, judicial independence will also weaken, with harmful consequences for the judiciary.

Judicial independence goes hand in hand with the independence of judges. A judge’s independence is also shaped by their conduct. Compliance with the code of ethics and guidelines for judicial behaviour is therefore crucial. Such compliance ensures that judges perform their duties independently and impartially, free from interference and conflicts of interest. Upholding ethical standards is thus an important part of building a judiciary that is principled, independent and just.

Ethics and law are closely connected. Earl Warren (1891–1974), a former Chief Justice of the United States, said: “Law floats in the sea of ethics.” The phrase suggests that ethics underpin the enforcement of law. Judges are therefore expected to uphold their code of ethics to ensure that the law is upheld: by maintaining ethical standards, judges uphold the law and help prevent breaches of their code of conduct. Ethics also reflect one component of the legal system: legal culture. Ethics precede the operation of the legal system and can even be understood as its social foundation. The rule of law grounded in ethics, therefore, produces enforcement that is not only formally legal but also morally legitimate.

To protect judges’ independence, the International Judicial Conference in Bangalore, India, adopted a global code of judicial conduct in 2001, known as the Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct. Its six principles are:

  1. Judicial independence (the independence principle), which guarantees the upholding of law and justice and is a prerequisite for realising the ideals of a state governed by the rule of law;

  2. Judicial impartiality (the impartiality principle), an inherent element of the judge’s role in resolving cases brought before them;

  3. Judicial integrity (the integrity principle), an inner quality reflecting each judge’s wholeness and balance, both as an individual and as a public official carrying out their duties;

  4. Propriety and decorum (the propriety principle), personal and interpersonal standards of conduct reflected in each judge’s behaviour, both as an individual and as a public official, and which inspire respect, authority and trust;

  5. Equality (the equality principle), which guarantees equal treatment for all on the basis of just and civilised humanity, without discrimination on grounds including religion, ethnicity, race, skin colour, sex, marital status, physical condition, socio-economic status, age or political views; and

  6. Competence and diligence (the competence and diligence principle), essential requirements for the proper and trustworthy administration of justice.

Justice and ethics are the principal pillars of the judicial system. Justice concerns not only the fair application of the law, but also the effect of judges’ integrity and ethics on public confidence in the courts. Satjipto Rahardjo described ethics as the “soul” that gives life to the law, enabling it to respond to society’s changing needs for justice. Ethical violations can undermine public trust in the legal system. Yet concerns remain over ethical issues that reflect the honour of judges. A judge’s honour is expressed in their rulings, the reasoning behind them and the entire decision-making process—which should be guided not only by legislation but also by a sense of justice and the wisdom of society. This vital task of enforcing ethical standards requires an institution: the Judicial Commission.

The Judicial Commission serves to perfect the independence of judicial power, in accordance with the principle, “Ma la yatimmu al-wajib illa bihi fahuwa wajib”: if an obligation cannot be fulfilled without something else, that means is itself obligatory. Establishing an independent judiciary is an obligation in a state governed by the rule of law.

The Judicial Commission is not itself an exercise of judicial power, but its existence is necessary to perfect that power. In this role, it is vital to safeguarding and enforcing judicial ethics. Judicial power should therefore be understood not merely as a legal principle, but as something closely connected to ethics. As a means of achieving the justice to which society aspires, law-making must incorporate ethical values that address not only outward conduct but also inner character.

The Judicial Commission’s ethical oversight of judges is needed as a wasilah (means) of securing judicial independence, both institutional independence and the personal independence of judges. This reflects the jurisprudential maxim “Al-wasilatu laha ahkamul-maqashid” or “Lil-wasail hukmul-maqashid”, which holds that the ruling governing a means is the same as that governing its objective. The Commission’s oversight function, as a means, stands on an equal footing with and depends on the three elements of the legal system: structure, substance and culture.

Law enforcement depends not only on written rules but also on the ethical values that underpin them. Ethics provide an essential moral guide to enforcing the law, ensuring that justice is achieved both properly and by proper means. In Islamic teaching, the command to act justly is stated in Surah An-Nahl, verse 90: “Innallaha ya’muru bil-’adli wal-ihsan” (“Indeed, Allah commands justice and excellence”).

As a principal pillar of law enforcement and justice, a judge must deliver justice to anyone who seeks it (ad officium justiciariorum spectat unicuique coram eis placitanti justitiam exhibere). A judge’s ruling must not be transactional or harm anyone (actus legis nemini facit injuriam).

The Judicial Commission’s oversight is essential when judges commit misconduct in their rulings. Bagir Manan has stressed that judges can use the pretext of freedom to abuse their power and act arbitrarily. Certain limits must therefore be established without sacrificing freedom as the essence of judicial power:

Judges must decide according to law. In every ruling, they must clearly identify the legal provisions applied to the specific case.

Judges must decide solely to deliver justice. Where necessary, they may interpret or construct the law, and even set aside applicable legal provisions.

They must adhere to general principles. When interpreting, constructing or developing the law, judges must remain firmly guided by the general principles of law and the general principles of natural justice.

There must be an enforcement mechanism. A mechanism must be established to enable action against judges who act arbitrarily or abuse their independence.

Judicial independence must therefore be balanced by accountability. The Judicial Commission serves as a counterweight, reconciling judicial independence with the requirement for accountability. Through its oversight role, it can help prevent judicial tyranny and abuse of power. This is the fundamental significance of the Judicial Commission’s oversight as a means of perfecting judicial power.

More from 9 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-judicial-commission-as-a-means-of-perfecting-judicial-power-1791539705)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8699767/komisi-yudisial-sebagai-wasilah-guna-menyempurnakan-kekuasaan-kehakiman), translated from Indonesian
Print