Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Irony of Indonesia Today

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
The Irony of Indonesia Today
Image: CNBC Indonesia

There is a classic maxim in political communication: “What you do speaks so loudly that I cannot hear what you say.” In simple terms, the line attributed to Ralph Emerson conveys that honest action matters far more than talk and rhetoric. Sadly, this paradox is starkly apparent in today’s corridors of power.

As our political elites flaunt strings of academic qualifications after their names and mobilise paid cyber armies, the public sees an increasingly acute deficit of morality.

We are witnessing education, which should be a beacon of civilisation, being forced to serve as cosmetic personal branding for the country’s leaders and elites. Today, we see political legitimacy being built—and sought through algorithms—rather than earned through tangible work.

Yet, looking back, this Republic was founded by a generation that placed knowledge and integrity on the highest pedestal. Mohammad Hatta, the Proclamation’s co-declarer, lived modestly until the end of his life. He treated books and rational thought as the nation’s moral compass.

Haji Agus Salim, a diplomat of world-class intellect who mastered more than a dozen languages, chose to live in a humble rented home, undazzled by the luxuries of power. Then there was Buya HAMKA, a self-taught scholar with vast intellectual horizons, who refused to yield to the tyranny of power, preserving the purity of his conscience and the truth of the knowledge he had acquired.

That intellectual legacy continued into later generations. We remember B.J. Habibie, a visionary technocrat of world standing who laid the foundations for science and modern industrialisation in Indonesia. Although, towards the end of his term, he had to endure the bitter manoeuvring of politicians in the House of Representatives, who rejected his accountability report, Habibie still left with his head held high.

He bequeathed pillars of democracy and a research ethic without carrying lasting resentment. At grassroots level, there was Romo Mangunwijaya. The German-trained architect and distinguished cultural figure from Yogyakarta chose to put his intelligence to practical use by supporting marginalised communities along the banks of the Kali Code. Romo Mangun showed that the highest expression of advanced education is radical empathy for ordinary people, demonstrated through action rather than rhetoric engineered by algorithms.

For those who came before us, education and knowledge were not tickets to seek the privileges of power, but instruments of emancipation for bringing about change. Drawing on the educational philosopher Paulo Freire, the true purpose of education is to free people from oppression (conscientização), not to reproduce new forms of oppression through falsehood and illusions of power.

Sadly, today we are witnessing a very different—and deeply painful—episode. In the hands of contemporary elites, educational status has been degraded into a mere ‘accessory’ to boost their image as ‘intellectuals’. Yet the elites’ educational histories appear unclear, while master’s, doctoral and even professorial titles suddenly attach themselves to their names.

From the perspective of communication studies, this phenomenon is a clear manifestation of hyperreality: a condition in which artificial images are deliberately created to obscure factual reality. It became more tangible when Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) revealed that RANS Entertainment received Rp 14.69 billion in public funds for influencer and political buzzer spending during 2024–2026.

At Jakarta’s provincial minimum wage of Rp 5.36 million a month, a worker would need 228 years to earn an amount equivalent to the income of a buzzer operation on Raffi’s scale.

Such a vast economic disparity, together with the manufacture of an instant and hollow leadership image, shows how the political communication model used by today’s elites has reduced leadership integrity to a commercial transaction. Everything is made instant: public opinion can be easily manipulated, criticism swiftly silenced, and popularity readily manufactured through algorithmic fabrication.

Yet public recognition and legitimacy are not commodities that can be bought in bulk with the backing of buzzer campaigns. A true leader does not build authority through amplification on screens or the manipulation of perception and paid image-making.

Leadership should be demonstrated through example and integrity in the real world. When a regime needs millions of paid hashtags just to convince people—and validate its claim—that it is doing its job properly, its elites are in fact announcing their own moral frailty.

The ultimate expression of this decline is the destruction of education’s most fundamental value: honesty. The uproar and scandals over alleged fake diplomas among political elites are no longer minor administrative disputes; they have become a major cultural tragedy. How can a leader demand that the public obey the law and live honestly when the foundations of their own intellectual achievements are shrouded in falsehood? This is the greatest irony.

The combination of bogus diplomas and false narratives spread by cyber armies produces what Jürgen Habermas called systematic communication distortion. This symbolic-level deception fuels public cynicism. It also paralyses critical thought and damages the foundations of deliberative democracy.

If Indonesia wants to escape the trap of being a developing country and make the leap to developed status, this crisis of ethics and communication must be broken. Political communication must no longer be the product of instant image-making.

The public and mass media must stop being dazzled by the cult of academic titles and the noise of paid social media trends. Political communication must return to a contest of track records, the exchange of arguments and evidence-based policy—not visual packaging or campaigns by buzzers and influencers.

Equally important is the need for the courage to be transparent about communication budgets and the accuracy of public data. The state must stop wasting public money on political buzzers and influencers to polish the image of those in power.

At the same time, state institutions must introduce rigorous, open-data authentication of public officials’ academic claims and diplomas. ICW has already initiated this effort.

The most fundamental task is to make higher education institutions bastions of civilisational integrity. Universities and educational institutions must not submit to becoming diploma mills for powerful elites.

Universities must have the courage to safeguard their academic dignity, reject all forms of pragmatic compromise and withdraw legitimacy from anyone who tarnishes the ethics of academic honesty. Professors from several universities have repeatedly voiced this concern, but efforts must not stop with individual cases.

Believe this: a strong national civilisation is not built by the deafening noise of millions of paid tweets on social media or the cheers of paid influencers. A civilised nation needs leaders who respect knowledge, uphold common sense and genuinely serve the conscience of the people—not artificially. Without integrity and genuine honesty, the dream of becoming a developed country will remain a mirage on the fleeting stage of political theatre.

It is time for today’s generation to learn again from the earlier generations of leaders who built this country through knowledge and integrity. Let us sit for a moment over a cup of black coffee and strengthen our resolve: ‘Indonesia can change!’

More from 11 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-irony-of-indonesia-today-1794397832)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261111155736-14-784338/ironi-indonesia-hari-ini), translated from Indonesian
Print