The Illusion of Fantastic Figures in the Food Sector: When Reason is Challenged by Rhetoric
As an academic and practitioner in the field of agribusiness, hearing fundamentally erroneous statements from public officials often triggers deep frustration. Recently, the public was shocked by a statement from President Prabowo Subianto, who claimed to have received reports that a single rice milling unit is capable of generating profits of up to Rp2 trillion per month.
Upon hearing such a claim, the urge to refute it is overwhelming. Where does a rice mill with such profits exist? Does it operate in a fairy tale or a mythical realm? Let us dissect this rationally using agribusiness logic and valid data. In the rice milling industry, the profit margin per kilogram of milled paddy is generally very thin, hovering around Rp300.
If a business intends to pocket a net profit of Rp2 trillion in a month, they would mathematically need to mill approximately 6.6 billion kilograms of paddy per month. Divided over 30 days, this means the factory would have to process about 220 million kilograms of paddy every single day. Which rice mill on earth possesses such capacity?
For an objective comparison, the Indonesian Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS) recorded that total national rice production for 2025 is around 34.69 million tonnes (or approximately 34.69 billion kilograms). Assuming an average rice yield from dried milled paddy of about 60 per cent, the total national paddy production for an entire year (not a month) is approximately 57 to 60 billion kilograms.
This implies that the claim of a single factory earning Rp2 trillion per month represents a figure that is macroeconomically nonsensical and far exceeds the real production scale of the entire country. For an international comparison, let us look at the industry in a developed nation like Japan. I use Japan as an example because I am intimately familiar with its agricultural system. Rice prices in Japan are much higher—roughly six times higher than in Indonesia.
However, based on operational data from large-scale industrial rice processing plants there (operating 24 hours a day with capacities of thousands of tonnes per month), the characteristics of this business remain a thin-margin, high-volume industry. Large-scale industrial plants in Japan generally record annual sales of around several hundred million to 10 billion yen, with net operating profit margins (1-3%) ranging from tens of millions to a maximum of 200-300 million yen per year. Converted to Rupiah, the annual turnover is approximately Rp1 trillion, and the annual profit is around Rp30 billion.
This means that the annual net profit for even a giant-scale factory in a developed country is at most in the tens of billions of Rupiah per year, not per month. If there were a rice mill in Indonesia capable of raking in Rp2 trillion every month, agribusiness practitioners and investors would have flocked to invest there years ago.
This error in data and logic is similar to the narrative in President Prabowo Subianto’s speech some time ago, which suggested that Indonesian farmers are already wealthy and can freely travel abroad. Certainly, there are wealthy ‘farmers’—a small number of corporate-scale farmers holding rights to thousands of hectares of oil palm land through large-scale capital schemes. However, the majority of farmers in Indonesia are smallholders, owning half or even a quarter of a hectare, living in a vastly different economic reality in rural areas.
These high-level statements, detached from empirical reality, demonstrate how policymakers often receive ‘Asal Bapak Senang’ (pleasing the boss) reports without adequate data verification. When the nation’s highest officials are fed erroneous data and endorse it without a critical filter, the direction of our national food policy is at stake. Therefore, judge for yourselves: is such a statement merely rhetorical bluster, or a reflection of acute ignorance regarding the reality of our agricultural sector?
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-illusion-of-fantastic-figures-in-the-food-sector-when-reason-is-challenged-by-rhetoric-1785484657)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260731141742-14-755486/ilusi-angka-fantastis-di-sektor-pangan-saat-nalar-ditantang-retorika), translated from Indonesian