The Hunt for the Marcos' hidden wealth continues
The Hunt for the Marcos' hidden wealth continues
By Jamil Maidan Flores
This is the last of a four-part series. The first three parts
describe the pursuit of the Marcos wealth through open and legal
means as well as a clandestine operation called "Big Bird" that
identified and exposed part of the Marcos deposits in Swiss
banks.
MANILA (JP): Many of the personalities involved in "Operation
Big Bird," the clandestine effort to expose and retrieve the
Marcos deposits in Swiss banks, are still very much around.
President Corazon C. Aquino was the highest official to be
involved in the operation. Much of the time, though, a cordon
sanitaire thrown around her by some of her officials had kept her
in the dark about how the operation was faring. She is now
enjoying her retirement. At the head of an active NGO promoting
human rights, she is now doing the criticizing instead of being
criticized. She recently joined forces with religious leader
Jaime Cardinal Sin in opposing an attempt by the administration
of President Joseph Estrada to amend the constitution.
Former Senate President Jovito Salonga who scuttled "Operation
Big Bird" also heads an NGO, one that is waging a campaign to
eliminate graft and corruption in the government. The setbacks
suffered by the Presidential Commission on Good Government
(PCGG), the agency tasked to go after the Marcos wealth, did
nothing for his political career as the agency continued to be
identified with him long after he had left it.
Sedfrey Ordonez, the Solicitor General who headed the
"Operation Big Bird" team, served as Philippine Ambassador to the
United Nations and later as Chairman of the National Commission
on Human Rights before his retirement from public life.
Joker Arroyo who, as Executive Secretary, prevented de Guzman
and Gen. Almonte from giving a final briefing to President Aquino
on the fate of "Operation Big Bird" is now doing well as a
legislator. He represents a Metro Manila district, Makati, in the
House of Representatives.
Ambassador Luis Ascalon, Philippine ambassador to Switzerland,
when "Operation Big Bird" was being carried out, has probably
retired from the Foreign Service.
The Swiss lawyers-Salvioni, Louenberger and Fontanat -- have
not been heard of in Manila press circles since the House
Committee on Public Accountability went to Switzerland, contacted
them and found them "uncooperative" in late 1990.
Jose "Peping" Cojuangco, the younger brother of President
Aquino who gave initial support to "Operation Big Bird" is out of
office again, probably as a result of the effects of electoral
reform laws that disallows a member of Congress from representing
the same district for more than three consecutive terms. He
remains a political power in his native province of Tarlac, but
his wife, Margarita "Tingting" Cojuangco, has lost her bid for
reelection as provincial governor.
The Group of Individuals that guided "Operation Big Bird"
through the labyrinth of the Swiss banking system has gone back
into the woodwork of that system. The Committee on Public
Accountability of the House of Representatives in 1991 had
considered recommending that the Philippine government negotiate
with them so that they could once more help in the quest for the
Marcos wealth. But they had been badly compromised financially
and operationally and, feeling badly burned by the Philippine
government, they probably would have turned down any offer.
Victor Bou Dagher, who conceived of the plan to convince the
Marcoses to issue certificates of power of attorney for the
withdrawal of their Swiss deposits, has remained an international
banker with wide contacts.
Ferdinand Edralin Marcos has been dead for some time but not
yet buried. His remains lie in state in a mausoleum in his
birthplace in northern Philippines.
His widow, the former Imelda Romualdez, recently celebrated
her 70th birthday with a magnificent bash that was worthy of the
extravaganzas of the Marcos era, prompting comments that the
Marcos hidden wealth is not so well hidden any more. She is an
elected member of the House of Representatives.
Why did she never rescind the power of attorney that she gave
Mike de Guzman? Maybe the Swiss contact got Marcos on the phone
at a time when Imelda was not around. And then maybe he forgot to
tell her. Maybe Marcos decided to leave the $13 million within
the reach of Mike de Guzman-just to see what would happen.
The rest of the Marcos family appear to be in good political
fighting shape although not one of them has won a nation-wide
election. They are by no means in any kind of political oblivion.
Michael Cesar U. de Guzman, the main and most mysterious
protagonist in the drama of "Operation Big Bird" after totally
vanishing from view for several years, has come back to Manila.
He is now in the satellite communication business.
De Guzman has been such a puzzling a figure one can hardly be
100 percent sure that he would not have run away with the Marcos
millions had those been transferred to his bank in Vienna. Or
that he was not working for the Marcoses all along while
pretending to help the Philippine government.
But, like the officials of the Aquino administration who
foiled him, de Guzman, too, must be given the benefit of the
doubt. Whatever he may turn out to be, the fact remains that
without him there would be no US$600 million held in escrow at
the Philippine National Bank today.
If there was one who totally believed that Mike de Guzman was
100 percent genuine, it was Gen. Jose T. Almonte. After the death
of "Big Bird," Gen. Almonte served in the Aquino administration
as Director of the Economic Intelligence and Investigation Bureau
(EIIB) of the Department of Finance. In that position he made
life miserable for smugglers, tax evaders and other viruses in
the Philippine economy.
In 1992, Fidel V. Ramos, a fellow veteran of the campaign that
defeated the agrarian rebellion of the 1950s, became President
and promptly took in Gen. Almonte as his National Security
Adviser. In that position, Gen. Almonte shone as the ideologue
and strategist for a number of major reforms in the country's
economic life.
In 1991, this writer had occasion to ask him if it was true
that at the height of his frustration with the Swiss banking
system, he had devised a plan to hijack a Swiss airliner as a way
of putting pressure on the Swiss to part with the Marcos money.
He laughed, pleading that he be not pressed for details as the
plan might still turn out to be useful one day. One could not be
100 percent sure he was kidding.
In 1997, both Gen. Almonte and Ambassador Sedfrey Ordonez were
in Jakarta as speakers at a seminar on the Philippine
independence centennial. Gen. Almonte was sorely tempted to throw
at least one sarcastic remark in the direction of Ordonez, but he
kept his peace. He had mellowed.
There was at least one trove that "Operation Big Bird" came up
with, a wealth of hindsight on what went right and what went
wrong with the hunt for the Marcos wealth, both legal and
undercover. Here are a few, which should be understood as
relevant only to the situation in the Philippines in the past two
decades.
1. It pays to be an early bird. If the Filipinos involved in
"Operation Big Bird" had begun to study Swiss laws and the Swiss
banking system and to develop a network of contacts only when
Marcos fell from power, nothing much could have happened. The
operation might not have been launched at all. Fortunately, they
had a head start of four years.
2. The government did well to take many legal initiatives and
actions to keep the other side on the defensive. Even when a
government is impoverished it can always fight on more fronts
than its opponents can if it is the one taking the initiative.
Thus, for example, there are still some 150 cases pending against
Mrs. Marcos. All but a few of these are probably not strong
cases. But they take away some of the time she could spend on an
offensive of her own. They give her something to worry about and,
more important, an incentive to negotiate.
3. Teamwork is essential. If the government is going to resort
to a clandestine operation, the effort should not be placed under
the control of a person who not only does not believe in it but
may also have something to gain, politically or prestige-wise,
from its failure. This is a matter of common sense and not a
judgment on the probity of former PCGG Chairman Salonga. Also,
effective internal communication should be sustained so that the
work of the legal people and the clandestine operatives are
coordinated and do not cancel each other out.
4. The public's hopes were not always kept at a realistic
level. Keeping such hopes in rein is easier said than done in a
country where the press sensationalizes every bit of intrigue it
can get its hands on. But a serious mass communication effort
must be made so that the public and the government itself are
protected from the effects of a massive letdown in case a
promising lead turns out to be a dud. Unfortunately, even if the
officials at that time had thought of doing this, it was in no
position to do so. Mistaking the government's information service
for a Marcos propaganda machine, the Aquino administration had at
that time already dismantled the government's information
service.
5. As a veteran of the anti-Marcos struggle told the House
Committee on Public Accountability in 1989, in the legal hunt for
the Marcos wealth, the government could have chosen its lawyers
more carefully. Again, this is easier said than done. But there
must be some good lawyers who are really out to help the
government rather than to milk the government. If you took a
little time to look for them, you might find them.
6. The government under three presidential administrations was
probably more disposed and ready to negotiate with the Marcoses
than it was willing to admit. For this it should not be
criticized. Given the experience of the legal hunt for the Marcos
wealth, the government should be actively looking for ways to
start negotiations. But this should be done professionally.
Teamwork is also necessary so that the people on the other side
clearly know who to negotiate with.
7. There are no minutes kept on negotiations that are
necessarily secret and so one does not know what actually went on
during such talks. The government side probably negotiated with
skill and tact. But it is always worth stating that the
government has to be realistic in negotiating and be able to make
an offer that is attractive enough for the other side. One of the
worst things that can happen is for the other side to feel that
the government is out to humiliate them. One basic demand that
they are sure to make is to be allowed to save face. And one way
to ruin the process is to insist that the other side must grovel.
It should be kept in mind that the goal is to get resources for
national development not to wreak vengeance.
8. During the process of negotiation, the government has not
always been considerate of the people's need and right to know.
This is not to say that the government should go into an orgy of
premature disclosures-that would make negotiations impossible to
even just begin. But neither should the government spring a fait
accompli on the people. That will always be taken for a betrayal.
But if the government is sure that it has achieved a win-win
result and if it is not totally lacking in mass communication
skills, it should be able to present the "package" gradually to
the people before the agreement is made final. Of course, in a
country with a freewheeling press like the Philippines, this is
easier said than done. And that is why no administration has done
it. But it should be done.
9. This may be the most important insight: Going after ill-
gotten wealth that has been stashed away may be important but it
is never the most important thing. It must be done because it is
the right thing to do but it should never be done as if the life
of the nation depended on it.
The Philippines is fortunate that it did not become overly
obsessed with the Marcos wealth and did not expend a
disproportionate part of its energies in pursuing it. The effort
was localized in a number of government offices, principally the
PCGG and the Office of the Solicitor General, while the rest of
the government went about the task of governing.
There were also free-lance operators like the relatives of
officials and former officials who sought to negotiate with the
Marcoses and, with the connivance of crony, allegedly ran off
with Marcos money deposited in Hongkong. There were enough of
these to make an industry of the hunt for the Marcos wealth, but
it was not a very big industry.
Reform was easily a thousand times more important than getting
at the Marcos millions or even billions. And considerable reform
was what two successive presidential administrations managed to
accomplish.
In the case of the Aquino administration, the focus was on
democratic reform and it carried this out very well. A few may
quibble and say the Aquino administration overdid it by
debilitating the presidency in order to ensure against the rise
of another Marcos in the future. In any case, through a new
constitution and various political reform laws, the old
democratic institutions were restored to a form that the people
are generally comfortable with. Philippine elections have become
considerably more democratic as a result of these reforms.
Under the presidency of Fidel V. Ramos, reforms were
concentrated on the economic field. The banking system was
strengthened and given the resiliency that would serve the
country in good stead during the Asian financial crisis. The
corporate sector was reformed by dismantling the monopolies that
had long stood in the way of progress in the country-and in this
Gen. Almonte, in his capacity as National Security Adviser to
President Ramos, played a major role.
He simply put into practice his long held belief that national
defense must be waged through economic and social reform. Had he
succeeded with "Operation Big Bird," his role in national
economic reform would still be the greater achievement and more
lasting contribution.
Today the Philippines is not doing too badly in spite of all
the economic doomsday predictions about a Joseph Estrada
presidency and recent jitters about the return of cronyism. The
national income is on the rise, inflation is down, interest rates
even more markedly down, the exchange rate has been stable for
many months, and a robust export sector is increasing the
government's supply of dollars and other foreign moneys.
With economic reforms firmly in place the Estrada
administration has the opportunity to move on to wide-ranging
social reforms, especially a sensible land reform. The Philippine
economy today is by no means of Olympian strength, but it is no
longer the sick man of Asia either.
In all this, the Marcos wealth has not mattered at all.
The author, a former Manila journalist, wrote this piece in a
strictly Philippine context without reference to the situation of
any other country. The views expressed here are his personal
views.)
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-hunt-for-the-marcos-hidden-wealth-continues-1447893297-1443217)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post