Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The HGU Moratorium and Investment Uncertainty

| | Source: nasional.kompas.com Translated from Indonesian | Legal
The HGU Moratorium and Investment Uncertainty
Image: nasional.kompas.com

This article is an opinion column; the views expressed are the author’s own and do not reflect the editorial stance.

Discourse on restructuring land ownership in Indonesia entered a new chapter in 2025 after the Minister of Agrarian Affairs and Spatial Planning/Head of the National Land Agency (ATR/BPN), Nusron Wahid, officially announced a moratorium on the issuance, extension and renewal of Cultivation Rights (Hak Guna Usaha, HGU).

The policy targets HGU applications covering 1.67 million hectares currently held up at the ministry.

The drastic step was taken as part of a strategy to re-evaluate and audit national agrarian reform governance.

Operationally, the moratorium focuses on three main agendas. First, conducting a compliance audit on rights holders’ obligations, including the provision of community plantations or plasma schemes of at least 20 per cent.

Second, detecting and firmly acting upon abandoned land that is not actively managed according to its designated use.

Third, identifying overlapping areas between HGU holdings and forest zones, customary lands, and residential areas in order to reduce the number of agrarian conflicts nationwide.

From a regulatory perspective, this corrective move rests on a number of existing legal instruments.

The main foundations include Government Regulation (PP) Number 20 of 2021 on the Control of Areas and Abandoned Land, and PP Number 18 of 2021 on Land Rights, Management Rights, Ownership of Flats and Land Registration.

Nevertheless, the moratorium has not been executed through the enactment of a new law or a formally promulgated ministerial regulation.

The licensing freeze is purely an act of executive discretion, through ministerial instructions to postpone the signing of decrees for HGU issuance or extension while the evaluation process is under way.

Herein lies a crucial issue that could spark lengthy debate.

An agrarian restructuring based on good intentions now comes face to face with the problem of legal certainty in the eyes of the business world.

In the discourse of state administrative law, the use of ministerial discretion to freeze public services on a massive scale without clear transitional regulation is likely to create problems, particularly conflicts of legal principles.

Discretion (freies ermessen) is indeed the lawful authority of public officials to fill legal gaps or resolve procedural obstacles.

However, when discretion is used to suspend civil business rights without a measurable time limit and without being bound by written legislation, the norm of the rule of law risks being displaced by governance by discretion.

This situation places businesses that have fulfilled all administrative and financial requirements in a grey area.

Businesses that have dutifully applied for new HGU licences or extensions now face uncertainty over the status of the land they manage.

From a legal perspective, this situation tests the government’s adherence to the General Principles of Good Governance (AUPB), particularly the Principle of Legal Certainty and the Principle of Legitimate Expectations.

Businesses that have invested long-term capital have a constitutional right to a predictable administrative process.

The absence of a clear transitional regulation echoes the warning of the legal philosopher Lon L. Fuller in his classic work, ‘The Morality of Law’.

When the audit’s success indicators and the duration of the moratorium are not set out transparently in a ministerial regulation, the public and investors struggle to distinguish between objective legal enforcement and subjective political decisions.

The Indonesian state administrative law expert Professor Philipus M. Hadjon also emphasised that discretion is not unrestricted freedom, but freedom tightly bound to legal purpose and proper principles of governance.

The use of discretion to collectively withhold land rights applications without measurable key performance indicators (KPIs) for abandoned land risks being judged as exceeding authority (détournement de pouvoir).

As a result, the noble intention of improving land governance risks being tainted by weaknesses in state administrative legal procedure.

The impact of a prolonged moratorium does not stop at administrative disputes; it will quickly spread to the financial sector and the national investment climate.

In the modern business law landscape, HGU rights are not merely surface land-use permits, a corporate obligation, but also high-value financial assets (underlying assets) underpinning corporate capital structures.

HGU certificates are the primary instrument pledged to banks to obtain credit facilities, bond issuances and refinancing for agribusiness and plantation projects.

When HGU status is frozen or under threat of re-evaluation without a definite time limit, banks and independent appraisers will automatically downgrade the risk rating of those assets.

The freeze on rights extensions could trigger technical defaults in corporate credit agreements because the collateral value is deemed to have depreciated or no longer meets bankability requirements.

This disruption creates a domino effect that will impair corporate solvency, restrict liquidity in the real sector and hold back business expansion in an agribusiness sector that employs millions of workers.

For the business world, unpredictable policy is far more dangerous than even stringent regulation. Investors can calculate the cost of strict rules.

Indonesia’s position in various ease-of-doing-business and regulatory quality indicators could come under pressure if this perception of uncertainty continues to grow in the eyes of domestic and foreign investors.

The eminent legal scholar Gustav Radbruch, in his theory on the basic values of law, stated that legal certainty is the certainty that the law itself is enforced, knowable and predictable by those subject to it.

When the value of certainty is sacrificed for the pursuit of social justice without procedural compromise, the justice achieved will be vulnerable and fragile.

Without legal certainty, the value of social justice becomes distorted into one-sided action that undermines business confidence in the sanctity of contract.

The long-term impact of postponing licences without a formal legal umbrella is the opening of large-scale legal disputes, both domestically and internationally.

Domestically, businesses materially harmed by the postponement of public services without a clear time limit have strong legal grounds to file suits with the State Administrative Court (PTUN).

Such suits could test the state’s fictitious negative actions or Unlawful Acts by the Government (Onrechtmatige Overheidsdaad) on grounds of administrative negligence.

Meanwhile, at the international level, a moratorium that ends in the revocation of HGU rights belonging to foreign-incorporated entities could trigger disputes at international arbitration bodies through the Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) mechanism.

Foreign investors could invoke violations of the Fair and Equitable Treatment (FET) principle and protection against creeping expropriation provided for in various Bilateral Investment Treaties.

The financial and reputational costs borne by the state as a result of arbitration disputes would be very damaging to Indonesia’s investment image.

Therefore, agrarian reform and business legal certainty should not be positioned as mutually exclusive, a zero-sum game.

The good intention behind land restructuring must be protected by robust regulation so that it is not legally defective.

The urgent step the government must take is to formalise the moratorium policy in written regulations, such as an ATR/BPN Ministerial Regulation or a Presidential Regulation.

Such formal regulation must contain three key elements: a firm and measurable moratorium time limit, objective criteria defining abandoned land and HGU violations, and a fair transitional mechanism for businesses that have acted in good faith.

Only through transparent legal formalisation can Indonesia uphold agrarian justice without sacrificing the legal certainty that underpins economic growth, the development of the national business world and even the foundations of Indonesian democracy in the future.

More from 7 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-hgu-moratorium-and-investment-uncertainty-1788799821)
Originally published by nasional.kompas.com (https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2026/09/07/10500051/moratorium-hgu-dan-ketidakpastian-investasi?page=all), translated from Indonesian
Print