Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The fiscal distress

| Source: The Jakarta Post

The fiscal distress

Measured by whatever financial ratios, President Abdurrahman
Wahid's government is indeed facing the daunting and immediate
task of tackling mountains of sovereign debts which threaten to
explode the fiscal deficit to an unmanageable level and cripple
the country's fragile economic recovery.

Further worsening the fiscal distress are the steadily
increasing domestic debts, which are incurred by the
recapitalization of banks, and mounting spendings on fuel, food
and electricity subsidies as well as social safety net programs
to protect the poor from the pains inflicted by the economic
crisis.

World Bank chief economist for the East Asia and Pacific
region Masahiro Kawai warned in Tokyo early this week that
Indonesia's external debts -- around US$150 billion, of which
about $77 billion is owed by the government -- is estimated to
balloon to almost as large as 100 percent of its nominal gross
domestic product, compared to only 48 percent at the end of 1997.
On top of that, the new government also inherited another huge
pile of debt papers (treasury bonds) issued to recapitalize state
and private banks. These domestic debts will swell to as large as
Rp 500 trillion ($71.5 billion) early next year when the
recapitalization is completed.

What makes things even murkier is that the government has not
much leeway for reducing spendings to curb the fiscal hemorrhage.
Asking for foreign debt relief not only is quite damaging to the
government's credit rating but also would involve a long, complex
process and impose harsh requirements that may unsettle the
newly-gained political stability.

Domestic debt service burdens cannot either be cut because
recapitalized banks, banned to sell their treasury bond holdings,
get real capital replenishment only from the treasury bond
interest payments. Since reductions of spendings on subsidies and
poverty alleviation programs are also out of question, the only
reprieve is expected from the restructuring of government
external debts to reduce debt servicing payments.

It is almost certain that the government will have to engage
in another round of debt restructuring with its sovereign lenders
at the Paris Club. Analysts have predicted that, without a new
package of debt rescheduling, principal repayments on its about
$77 billion foreign debts alone will shoot up to $5 billion next
year, from the current $2 billion, and further rocketing to $9
billion in each of 2001 and 2002.

The sharp spike in debt payments will come after the expiry
next March of the two-year moratorium on $4.2 billion in
principal payments that Indonesia and its sovereign creditors
agreed to last year at the Paris Club meeting.

Multilateral lenders do not either offer much help to remedy
the budget pressures as the World Bank, the International
Monetary Fund and the Asian Development Bank may have to restrain
from extending new loans as they are already edging close to
their country limits in their exposure to Indonesia.

It was officially estimated near the end of the previous
(Habibie) government last month that at least $6 billion of
sovereign debts falling due in the next two years should be
rescheduled to prevent the state budget from an unmanageable
fiscal deficit explosion.

But even if this rescheduling target is achieved and both the
Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency and the privatization of
state enterprises can achieve their revenue targets, the fiscal
distress will persist after one or two years if the recurrent
stream of revenues from domestic taxes cannot be increased
significantly. It should be noted that debt rescheduling only
postpones, does not stop, debt payment burdens, and asset sales
and privatization is only a once-off generator of revenue.

As long as the tax system is riddled with many budget
loopholes, as it is now, and the tax base remains narrow due to
massive tax evasion, the government will continue to face a
fiscal liquidity crisis and will increasingly depend on foreign
borrowings to make ends meet, even after the economy returns to a
robust growth path within two years.

The fiscal distress could even worsen if the government, in a
bid to pacify the clamor for broad autonomy from the provinces,
simply surrenders to their demands for up to 75 percent of
natural resource-generated revenues without first clearly
demarcating and defining taxing and expenditure powers vested in
different jurisdictions.

Hopefully, reform of the tax administration and management
system will be emphasized in the new set of economic
restructuring measures currently being prepared by the government
and the International Monetary Fund.

More from 20 November 1999 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-fiscal-distress-1447893297-1413478)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print